Chilmark is a bit out of the way, which is why we chose to stay at the Picket house. Previous reviews where excellent, so we booked for several days. The owner and her children are delightful, but the house is old, which is not a bad feature but was not in the greatest shape, as it was dilapidated and really... more

We booked two nights at the Capt. Flanders House and when we arrived I was disappointed with the king bedroom ,private bath upstairs in this 18th C farmhouse. The stairway leading to the two upstairs rooms is original and a bit difficult to navigate. When Annie,the innkeeper, saw my dissappointd face she immediately said she would try to make us... more

It has been a year since we were at the Pickett House; it has taken that long for me to decide whether to tell the truth. We went to another nearby island this summer and stayed in an inn which looked to be similar on the www. They were very different. The Pickett House did not deliver what they promised... more

We just returned from a stay at the Inn at Blueberry Hill. The grounds are nice and the manager, Niall, a charming hard worker but there are some disappointments. The rooms are ok. The walls are thin and you can hear your neighbors next door and above. We had the air conditioning system outside our door and that was very... more

I recently stayed at the Inn at Blueberry Hill with my wife and while the inn is set on a very nice property and has great potential, we were disappointed in the quality of the service, the air conditioning and the general lack of value given the somewhat high priced rooms. The inn is apparently under new management and the... more

My daughter and I had dinner at Theo's a few weeks ago and I, who am not easily impressed by high end restaurants, was very impressed. There wasn't a dish that we ordered that wasn't memorable. I gather the menu changes nightly. The Mediterranean fish soup was so good I had to ask for the ingredients which included fennel and... more

Wow! I am astonished at the negative review above! I stayed at the Captain Flanders House this month, and it is the ONLY place I would stay on the island. I stayed in the lovely stone cottage and it was very comfortable. In fact, it was very quiet and peaceful, being at the opposite end of the island from all... more

This place is unbelievably yummy! Just a little shack by the side of the road - eat outside on the picnic tables or take your food to the beach. The fried shrimp are to die for! The place is a bit pricey but worth the splurge. more

My husband and I have been vacationing on MV for years. We stayed at this B&B before, so we decided to go there for my birthday early October. In the past we overlooked the flaws because of the extraordinary setting, but on this weekend there was no heat....and no wood for the fireplace. It was freezing in the cottage. The... more

My husband and I stayed at The Inn At Blueberry Hill in July and we were pleasantly surprised. The staff was extremely helpful making us feel very welcomed. Niall Reid, The General Manager was charismatic and delightful as well as very informative about the island. Everyone at the Inn went out of their way to make us feel comfortable. Our... more

I spend all my summers in Chilmark, MA and I can hardly stand to go a day without being on Lucy. Its the most beautiful beach, and its got a nude section, HOORAY!! If you are in Chilmark, I hope you can make time to stop by. more

The property is quite lovely, bucolic and isolated. The staff is friendly and eager to please. However, the actual physical structures are so badly constructed that any sound, be it clearing of a throat at 5:30 a. m., or the mere turning on of a water faucet in another room, will be cause for alarm if you're trying to sleep.... more

I almost hate to review this restaurant for fear that it will be overrun with people who don't appreciate the quiet, peaceful, relaxed aura of this place. Theo's is a special place on the Island. It's expensive but well worth it. We love the open air feeling of the screened in porch with the view of the pines and stone-wall... more

It's the most beautiful beach I have ever been on. My girlfriend and I rented a house in town and tanned there for a month. more

Small selection, mostly fried food. Tasty, but not really meal-worthy. more

This place is too cute. Stand on line to order from very pleasant boy (who seemed to be 12-years old!). Get drinks from machine on premises or bring your own concoction! I will say we over ordered -- my son and I EACH had a medium chicken fingers and split large fries. It was so good we gobbled it down... more

My wife and I spent 3 nights here for our first anniversary. We figured that the "Up-Island" B&B would be the quieter and more romantic than others. The Pickett House didn't disapoint!!! The B&B is perfectly located amid farms and meadows and is just down the street from Chilmark Market and a short bike ride from Menemsha (a nice litttle... more

We recently spent two weeks on Martha's Vineyard, and stayed at three different high-end properties. The Outermost was by far our favorite. It's one of those places where, if you looked at it piece by piece, you might be tempted to dwell on its shortcomings. But the whole package is marvellous. Yes, there is no air conditioning. We were there... more

I recently had the opportunity to stay at the quaintest little home on Martha's Vineyard. I had the most pleasant visit. Let me tell you about this home that is an "old vineyard style" home that has been marvelously done in antiques and with an eclectic style by its owner. She is a wonderful host and definately dedicated to perfection... more