We noticed that you're using an unsupported browser. The TripAdvisor website may not display properly.
We support the following browsers: Windows: Internet Explorer, Mozilla Firefox. Mac: Safari.

Sag Harbor

Free Newsletter

Interested in Sag Harbor?

We'll send you updates with the latest deals, reviews and articles for Sag Harbor each week.

Sag Harbor Travel - Before You Go


Traveller Articles – advice from real travellers
Background

Traveller Reviews on Sag Harbor

Blue Skey

1 of 5 stars
Bronx, NY
1 Jan 2010

The previous commenter is indeed correct - Spinnakers is now Blue Sky. This was our first trip to Sag Harbor (we usually stay on Shelter Island, but decided to take the ferry across for lunch). Being that it was December, not much was open so we were happy to try Blue Sky. In theory, there menu looked pretty good and... more

The American Hotel

5 Dec 2009

Food used to be quite good here. Now it's a B-, certainly not worth the price in itself. Wine list is still excellent and there are some good values to be found. Service is casual, even blase. Great atmosphere, though. more

The American Hotel

27 Nov 2009

I have always loved the American Hotel for drinks and special occasions. This year, for Thanksgiving, my fiance and I decided to go to the American Hotel. We made a reservation on November 1st when we went there for a birthday dinner. When he called to confirm the time, he was told 3:30 was not available, so we went at... more

Write Your Own Review

Been to Sag Harbor? Share your experiences!

More Sag Harbor Resources