Interested in Shelter Island?
We'll send you updates with the latest deals, reviews and articles for Shelter Island each week.
Get your quick guide to the top hotels, restaurants and things to do.
We have stayed at this hotel many times. The rooms are a little small but the property has a lot of charm. Its a great place to hang out. The beach is not as nice as the beach that the Pridwin and Sunset Beach motel are on but you can always drive there. I haven't stayed at Sunset Beach but... more
We had a nice stay at the Dering Inn. Its located very close to the Shelter Island ferry (North), the room was rather large with separate bedroom and living room. There was also a kitchen in the room. If you want a nice relaxing vacation it is a good place to stay. The only issue we had was that there... more
My family and I just spent this past weekend in one of the cottages at the Pridwin and well we found it to be way too expensive for the accommodations that they provided. The first thing you realize is a strong dampness in the room with a strong mildewy order. The decor was very outdated alla 70"s early 80's wood... more
Been to Shelter Island? Share your experiences!
