Stayed at the Sugar Mill for 2 nights following a week of sailing BVI... Both my husband and I were absolutely delighted. Great food, good wine list, very pleasant staff. Our room - a one bed plantation house suite - was very roomy, well decorated, and comfortable - and the hammock on the balcony was divine! Housekeeping was excellent. Bathroom... more

This little hotel is indeed a gem! The view overlooking Apple Bay is gorgeous, the beach and waters picture post card perfect. Our poolside room was attractive and comfortable, just steps from the romantic dining room and beach, and the outside stone shower was an extra nice touch. The staff members of the Sugar Mill Hotel are really exceptional. Every... more

We visited the Sugar Mill after 5 days on Virgin Gorda. After a long, hot ferry ride, I was initially underwhelmed by the Inn (the initial atmosphere was a big change from the large resort we had stayed at). However, it ended up being a wonderful stay. The staff were very friendly (if a little quiet), the room very comfortable... more

We were looking to spend our 10th anniversary somewhere fun so we chose the British Virgin Islands. We booked the hotel directly and the manager was very accomodating over the phone and through email. Everything went well. We arrived later in the day and checked into the hotel. We happened to be coming in on Monday night, where there were... more

Just returned from 7 days at the Sugar Mill Hotel in the beautiful island of Tortola. From arriving at the hotel to our time of departure we had an amazing time. We were on this great package called the Adventure Package which basically was a blue print for everything we did but we decided our own itinerary from car rental,... more

My wife and I (both 35 years old) stayed at the Sugar Mill in mid-March for one week. Our room (the Cottage) was quite comfortable with a beautiful outdoor shower. We also appreciated the size of the room which was relatively large. The cleaning staff consistently did a nice job of cleaning the room. However, the room offers only a... more

It is only as we struggle towards the end of yet another grim New York winter that the true charms and heady excitement of the Sugar Mill Hotel are thrown into the highest possible relief. This quiet gem of a hotel sits as far from the airport and Tortola's main urban center, Road Town, as it is possible to get... more

This is the perfect intimate getaway on Tortola, BVI. We discovered it last year, returned this year and plan to return again next winter. The beach is never crowded and there is good opportunity to snorkel along the reef. The views from the rooms are breathtaking. We ate at the restaurant every night for over a week as the food... more

We just recently returned from a two-week jaunt through the British Virgin Islands, ending up at the Sugar Mill for two nights. I had heard wonderful things about this hotel for many years, especially the food. All pre-trip dealings with the hotel were handled efficiently, promptly, and courteously by Liz in the front office. We were very early for arrival,... more