Initially this hotel is charming and cute. The main building is a very old plantation with wood plank floors. There is a bar attached that has no windows and the bar staff are amazing. I will say too that almost all the hotel staff are very nice. However I would not recommend staying here at all. I called when we... More

I was on STX to meet up with a group of friends, some staying at Caravelle and some islanders. I chose the Comanche because the Caravelle was booked- lucky break for me! I had reserved a Jr. Suite, but when asked was told that that level room didn't have a TV viewable from bed, which was important to me. They... More

The Hotel was rustic and beautiful. Like a trip back in time. Very clean and had great service. I could only find a couple things wrong with it. It was impossible to sleep in. Roosters crowing (5:30 am) and loud noices from the street. And the foot steps on floor above. If not for these issues I would rate it... More

I booked this hotel/trip as a surprise for my fiance's b-day, just for the weekend. And after reading some of the reviews I was a little concerned about what to expect. Now that I have actually stayed there I am happy that I did. Initially when we arrived in Christiansted from the airport there was a local festival called "Jump... More

Although the staff was very nice, the room was basic and ok, the pool was dark green. We moved to another hotel after just a couple days.

I was invited on a trip so I wasn't aware of the area or hotel. My expectations weren't initially met but my experience in the area was good for what it was. Better company would've made my trip better but that's a side issue :-(. Just be careful of the room you reserve. Our initial room was in the building... More

This historic hotel, grounds and pool has character and is well kept. The requests we had were promptly handled. True, there is no elevator, but steps are good exercise. The room was very clean and the Sealy pillow top mattresses were heavenly. Yes, parties and receptions can be loud until 10 p.m. or you may hear the Comanche Yachtless bar... More

The location of this Hotel is EXCELLENT, you a just steps from the BOARDWALK. I read the reviews before booking this hotel and i was a little unsure based on what i read. Upon our arrival there was a Wedding Party going on, with a VERY LOUD DJ. I had been traveling all day to get there and i thought... More

I loved this hotel. I stayed in the Historic suite. The only complainant I had was the VERY thin walls. I could my neighbors below me laughing and talking all night. They were SUPER loud and the hotel staff did ask them to quiet down. The hotel was full and I never heard any other neighbors, so I'm guessing that... More