We just returned from 4 days at Pigeon Cay. We had a WONDERFUL room, views, and customer experience. Leslie and Ned (U.S. expats) are so accommodating! The beach is just steps from your room. Our 3-bedroom house was fantastic. They fixed a nice dinner for us on our first night. The beach bar (honor system drinks) is a great place... More

The most amazing beach experience for a first timer in the Caribbean. Cat Island is isolated but safe and peaceful. The Pigeon Cay Beach Club is privately located with self contained cottages, meters away from the most refreshing clean blue sea!!! A very quaint beach club owned and run by an American couple who are fabulous hosts. They respect the... More

oh my gosh, where to start...lol...well, we did pick the best place to stay on Cat Island!!! It was the best 10 days we have ever had!! Ned and Leslie were just awesome host, and yes, Ned is a very good Chef....our stay was blissful,quiet when we wanted it to be,and the view was just breathtaking!! It is just what... More

We enjoyed our time here. Very relaxing, off the beaten path. Ned is a very good cook, enjoyed the dinners on the beach. Good clean accommodations with most of the amenities you might expect. The best thing about the place is its location right on the beach, great white sand. We really enjoyed sleeping with the windows and doors open,... More

Pigeon Cay is a beautiful relaxing getaway from modern craziness and hectic life, and a perfect place to enjoy the colors and nature of the Bahamas in their unspoiled ways. Pigeon Cay cottages are private but comfortably near one another, and very clean. The silence of the place is amazing and interrupted only by the sound of the waves! The... More

We stayed at Pigeon Cay Beach club on Cat Island, Bahamas in April of 2012 and had a wonderful time. The beach is beautiful with miles stretching out to walk-you won't see another soul. The weather was great, about 80 (same as the water temp!) and clear turquoise water. Excellent snorkeling available-Ned and Leslie will show you the best spots.... More

My wife and I spent Christmas for the first time in the Bahamas at Pigeon Cay Beach Club. This was my second stay at Pigeon Cay on Cat Island. The first time was in 2002 and the beach at Pigeon Cay is still one of the most beautiful, remote white sandy beaches in the Bahamas. We bicycled to the North... More

If you're like we were, it was impossible to tell which hotel to book on Cat. They all looked similar, and seemed like all of them had pretty good reviews. Well, here is our review of most of the hotels on Cat (we stopped into each and had either lunch, hung on the beach or drank from all the honor... More

We just got back from Pigeon Cay beach club on Cat Island ,this was by far the best vacation I have been on .Can not say enough about the place and Leslie and Ned ,wonderful people, could not have done more to help and make our stay the best. I have never bothered to write a review before but wanted... More