I hesitate to write this review because I worry that I may not be able to get a reservation in the future. I recently went to Isla with my bff for a week and spent 3 nights at this little slice of paradise. I will start by saying that it exceeded my expectations, and I already knew that I was... More

This was our first visit and we had a fantastic time! All of our expectations were not only met, but exceeded. We counted on Steve to provide information about our travel around island and he did not disappoint. Steve is the ultimate host and the staff is wonderful with tremendous attention to detail. From the yummy breakfasts to the towel... More

This is our third trip to Casa Sirena, and it feels like our home away from home now. From the moment we arrive, greeted by our dear friend Steven, cool towels, and a cold beer, it's all just fantastic. As previous reviews have noted, the fantastic breakfasts and Happy Hour on the rooftop are standouts every time. The entire place... More

Just off the ferry, trailing our luggage behind us, "only another half block to go" Paul says. Sure enough one short block and the turn around the corner sports a small huddle of people looking our way with the sound of luggage rollers on the cobbley street a huge cheer erupts,"they're here, now the happy hour can begin. Up to... More

This was our 3rd visit in 4 years, and my husband and I never tire of Casa Sirena. It is the perfect 5 day getaway to cure the winter blues. Fun, laughs, sunshine and great food = heaven! Looking forward to our next trip!

Another great trip - this time I brought my friends and filled the hotel for my birthday! The happy hours and breakfasts continue to be the best part of the experience and Steve hired a mariachi band for to serenade me for my birthday! He also took us to a few local restaurants we would have never found on our... More

We choose Isla Mujeres, Mexico and this hotel all based off of reviews from this site...and we were both so happy we did. Although the owner was not there during our stay, Beverly made our stay one to remember. Besides seeing that we were comfortable and well taken care of she was just so much fun to be around. Some... More

I returned to Isla Mujeres and Casa Sirena for the third time in 2 1/2 years. The first time I traveled solo in July, the second time I brought family in August and the third I roomed with a friend in March. All three times were different experiences, but all times were consistent with sunny island weather, and amazing service... More

My girlfriend and I had a great time on Isla Mujeres, especially due to Steve and his partner Dennis’ incredible hospitality. The rooms were very clean and the cleaning staff made super cute figures using the towels. Breakfast was fresh and delicious every morning and we were offered a choice between an American (eggs + bacon) and a traditional Mexican... More