Returned from a three day Festive break at the Caledonian, was a wee bit put off with some of the reviews, but decided to reserve judgement. Could not have enjoyed our stay more !! At all times reception, waiting and service staff were very friendly, helpful and keen to help in any way. Rooms were very clean and comfortable with... more

Stayed in hotel from 2.01.2010 to 4.01.2010. Best feature was the view over the bay. The room was clean and a good size - more than we could say about the bed - which was a small double surrounded by a huge headboard. with 2 protruding bedside tables. Getting out of bed required caution because of these. The dining room... more

Stayed at this hotel for Hogmanay. The General Manager is hands on and his staff are the most polite and obliging group I have ever met. Nothing is too much trouble and any problems are attended to immediately. The food is of an extremely high quality and the menus offer a wide choice which caters for all tastes. The situation... more

We booked this hotel via booking.com and got a good rate for the one night we were staying. We picked it because of the location of the ferry terminal which we were needing the following day to travel over to the isle of mull. We arrived at about 8.30 and dinner is served until 9pm so we ordered room service.... more

On arrival found the receptionist rude infact the whole time we were there she never once looked up smiled or acknowledged us. Room was clean but the most uncomfortable bed I've ever slept in and the room was noisey. Bar staff were more interested in chatting to a work colleague they were serving and while the other one swept the... more

I arrived at the Caledonian Hotel to be warned immediately that there may be street noise late at night when the pubs came out and if it was very noisy to let them know and they would call the police. The room was clean if small - a twin room at the back of the hotel and the small radiator... more

Had a very enjoyable stay at this hotel on 6th + 7th November. It was our 39th wedding anniversary, I wanted it to be a little bit special. Have stayed often at Oban, trying various hotels and this one proved to be the best so far. Location is tremendous and we had a huge bay view room. Just watching the... more

Having had a bad experience trying to get lunch at this hotel in the summer, it was with some trepidation that we booked to stay here after a function. We were very pleasantly suprised by the quality of the room and check in. The staff were friendly and helpful and the room was great with a sea view. The food... more

The hotel was good considering it is only a 3* and detractors should remember this, and the fact that it is only around £70 per double room per night B&B, before deriding it. However, we did not eat in the hotel, apart from breakfast which was good, so cannot comment on the food or that service. The one negative we... more