Honestly this entire review may be jaded as I was spoiled in 2 other Hotels in Italy in Rome and Sienna but this hotel tries to be more than it is. I initially booked a room for myself and another and no problem when we wanted two seperate rooms. However the rooms were somewhat small,musty,and in the second building and... more

Really enjoyed our stay at the Villa San Paolo. It is a short drive (10 mins) from San Gimignano and has great views over the town. The staff are friendly and helpful and there is a very nice atmosphere in the hotel without it being too formal. The hotel is tastefully decorated and the spa was great. Dinner was lovely... more

I booked a stay here for a week over Easter with my husband and 12-year old son. My son was miserable because of the awful food in the restaurant and snack bar, and not being allowed access to the swimming pools or spa. My husband hated the food and wanted to leave after the first day. I understood their unhappiness... more

The purpose of the stay was to wind down and explore San Gimignano. Did both. However the hotel wasen't quite ready for us. The pool wasn't opened for the season, though it was meant to be. The pool restaurant opened the day we left, and was ok, nothing more or less. The staff gave the impression of not being ready... more

We felt so at home. It feels like Scottsdale, Arizona, very southwestern. And the spa. The heated pool was wonderful. The massages left a lot to be desired, in fact horrible. They had a designer Fashion Show at the pool, dining at the pool, great breakfasts, very modern, with balconies AND THE VIEWS!!! Wow! more

We upgraded to the "Prestige" double room vs. the standard, which is just below the suites. We were very disappointed by the room. It hadn't been updated in years, the bathroom smelled and it was small. The hotel has a gorgeous view, which they've managed to put car parks in front of every angle. They moved us to the suite... more

Lovely hotel set in beautiful Tuscan countryside about 10 minutes drive from San Gimignano and within easy reach of a good number of interesting places to visit in mid-Tuscany. Well married mixture of old and new so far as the building was concerned. There is a well laid out pool area incorporating some shady areas and a delightful poolside restaurant.... more

Pros : - Excellent location from San Gimignano - only 5 minute drive - beautiful gardens - as part of the restored villa side - there is a more modern annex but blends in well with the villa - excellent views of the San Gimignano Town from the gardens - outside pool in the gardens with the excellent view :)... more

Villa San Paolo is a beautiful hotel in the heart of the Tuscany Countryside. After trawling the internet for a suitable hotel for our wedding reception and honeymoon in Tuscany we found Villa san Paolo, I cannot describe in words how beautiful the grounds of this hotel are, 42 Guest flew over to italy with us and every guest could... more