we stayed here for a murder mystery weekend. Staff were very good and so was the murder mystery. The dinner was quite poor, cold and quite fatty. Breakfast was good, warm and lots of it but breakfast on a sunday finishes at 9.30 am!! One of the group got a HUGE room and the rest of us got tiny little... more

having been recommended this hotel by a very close friend i was simply astonished that it exceeded all my expectations more

Stayed at the Maitland 13th Feb was there for a murder mystery night. It was FAB............. The hotel was lovely Staff pleasant & helpfull Dinner & Breakfast lovely Rooms were small but great (clean & tidy) The only gripe i had was i felt it was cold, But i am usually always cold, But soon warmed up after a few... more

I fail to understand how this hotel achieves 4 stars. The rooms are small, tatty and need refurbished. Staff were difficult to find and not particularly friendly. The location is great with the town within easy walking distance. more

My husband booked a 2-night dinner b&b deal for us after seeing this hotel's website. It looked as if it had lovely rooms and pleasant views, and the room available was described as a 'premium' room. What a misrepresentation. When we got there we were offered the kind of hotel room you'd expect to find in a seedy low budget... more

just spent another couple of nights at this great hotel can not fault it. The staff are so friendly and nothing is a bother, rooms may not be the largest but how long do you actually spend in the rooms. Food excellent and such a lovely atmosphere in this hotel.I would go back in a minute. more

Booked superior double room with a "view" for New Year 3 night break. The "view" - the sky lights of the hotel's dining room, the "superior" bedroom was large with 2 single beds pushed together, very dated and tatty, the carpet was filthy and the hole in the wall which passed for a wardrobe was a joke! Bathroom had large... more

I have just stayed at the Maitland House Hotel in Haddington and I have had a really great time. I had read the previous reviews and was very concerned. Today I can confirm that our total experience was very enjoyable. The new brasserie service and food experience was fantastic. I can understand why they have received there 4 stars from... more

Booked a late deal 2 nights dinner bed and breakfast for under 200 pounds. Fantastic value for money. The Staff were very pleasant , helpful without being intrusive. The food was particularly good, no faults with the food whatsoever, presentation was superb and steak etc. cooked exactly as we had ordered (which is refreshing!!!). The room was in modern autumn... more