Our condo at Etta Place was quite pleasant.
PLUSES: Large, clean, nicely decorated, located at a handy spot in town. Furniture was comfortable. The whole condo felt quite cheerful.
MINUSES: We had a few qualms about leaving our car in the parking lot, which also served nearby long-term rental units that weren't nearly so nice.
Also, neither of the two doors to this condo had a deadbolt lock.
Incidentally, do book directly with ResortQuest -- they treated us great after Bookit.com botched our original reservation and left us with with NO RESERVATION when we got into town!
When in Telluride, be sure to take a look at Bridal Veil Falls. If you're reasonably fit, you can walk the trail right up to the falls; if not, just park your car where the road ends, and you can still get a good look at it. Beautiful.
more