We were given a room directly over the bar, where a band played until midnight each night. Immediately upon arrival we asked to change rooms because the noise was unbearable. The only other room they had available was a smaller room with a double bed (rather than a queen that we paid for). We took the room because it wasn't... more

Where to start? This could be such a great place but it fails to meet expectations. Firstly we arrived to be given a key for a room in the carriage house rather than the grand mansion house. The room (having negotiated the poorly maintained worn down entrance area including holes in doors rather than doorhandles) was in fact a store... more

My family and I stayed at the lighthouse Inn over the weekend of July 12th and 13th 2008. We arraived around 8pm on Staurday night after a long day in NYC. When I arrived at the desk they had no reservation for me and I could see by the crowd they had a wedding going on. The lady at the... more

My wife and I booked a saturday night for a friends wedding nearby. Location was excellent. We were booked into room 7 in the mansion. Our room was a disgrace. the kitchen exhaust fans blew the kitchen smoke directly into our room. The oversized windows were patched around a small room AC unit. The seal was less than perfect. In... more

This hotel is a gracious, old building with nice rooms. The service at the desk was good and the people in the tavern kept the kitchen open for us and service and food was good. I could see though that the hotel is a bit run down, but overall, the furniture etc. was fine. The cleanliness was fine. We had... more

We had hoped for a great night there. Unfortunately, the room we got was NOT anything like the pics on their website. It was MAYBE a step up from a college dorm room...no view...the hotel is FAR removed from the water...AND...for $175.00! The two staff members we saw at the front desk (checking in and out) were very nice. We... more

I am from Connecticut and now living in New York City. We went to the Inn seeking a place to get the peace and quiet of CT without staying with family. Our room was lovely in cream colors with a picturesque view of the water across the street. The bathroom was extra large and sparkling clean. Diner in the tavern... more

After patiently waiting through 27 rings to their direct hotel phone number, I was greeted by an automated answering system, where I was left on hold for 19 minutes...I should have hung up the phone....however based on their beautiful website (lies, lies, and more lies) I remained. The "operator" could not quote hotel rates, could not tell me what rooms... more

The same people who slam my five-star resort in Cancun must also stay at the Lighthouse. Come on people. For seventy bucks through Expedia, I thought it was just fine. We had rooms 11 and 23, both of which were very nice. The rooms are extremely comfortable, warm, cozy, and if the 1902 Tavern downstairs doesn't make you fall in... more