The Fodors book said that this was a nice place to stay so my wife booked us there. We like to spend our money on the mom and pop establishments and everything we read seemed really nice. When we arrived the front desk person seemed a bit dis-interested in us, but we were checked in promptly. We were told our... more

My wife and I were in Florida for a romantic vacation, to the point of if the right spot is found we would get married. Checked out several spots and did not find anything to our liking. We saw an ad for the Seafarer and thought we would stop to check it out. Yes it is a simple resort type... more

Would I return? Definately! This was our second stay at Seafarer. Look, we are divers. We spend our time diving not hanging out in at a tiki bar with room service. The place isn old, yes, but it has weathered MANY hurricanes, and it was clean. The staff was friendly and very accomidating. This is our 2nd stay here and... more

The room was functional, but not a resort as the name states. Don't come here with high expectations. The window privacy was marginal at best due to the inadequate coverage of the drapes - luckily the extra towels in the room worked well as drapes. The room showed it's age, but was clean. Were there some bugs in the room?... more

This is the perfect divers hotel. We booked with Garden Cove Divers who also arranged the hotel. Room was clean, there was soap, plenty of towels for all 4 of us, coffee and filters were provided along with plenty of silveware. We were in the Beach House on the Bay with a great view. Room had everything you needed, kitchen... more

Let me start off by saying...YOU PAY FOR WHAT YOU GET. This place was pretty cheap and by looking at their pictures online, it didn't look too bad. But, pictures can be deceiving. This place had insects of all sorts inside the rooms and bugs on the bathroom counter. LOTS OF MOLD!! The shower was covered in mold. I had... more

The best thing that you could say about our room at this place was that it was clean and quiet. Other than that it was mighty basic. Kind of a glorified shed with a mattress that was at least 50 years and windows that were held in place with peeling tape. Definitely Keys Funky and not even cheap! more

After living in FL for 2 yrs., our family of four decided to take a Keys dive trip over 4th of July before being transferred back to the Chicago area. We made a reservation at the Seafarer and had to pay 2 nights ($333.50)upfront. We arrived after dark and were shown to very sorry accommodations. Wiring was exposed, holes in... more

Stayed here for one night in April on our way from Key West up to Naples. When we got there it was pretty empty so we had a choice of most rooms. As we were only staying one night and it was already early evening we went for the cheapest. Having said that in my opinion $80 isn't that cheap,... more