We just got married and decided to find a hotel in the keys. Everything was full, but the staff from the Seafarer found us a nice little cozy cottage and gave us a great price as a honeymoon deal. It was conveniently located and the staff was most certainly outstanding. Can't wait to go again!! We are already planning!

We were 2 couples looking to find old Florida style charm and happy to find vacancy with no advanced reservations. Our cottage #4 certainly fit the bill. Although not fancy by any means, the one bedroom with 2 full beds and a hide-a-bed, kitchen and small bath exuded Florida of yesteryear. The furnishings were outdated, shower was slow drain, and... More

My wife and I stayed at the Seafarer for 6 nights in early January. The location is perfect, and the layout is conducive to privacy, consisting of several small buildings stretching from near the road (the unit we had, and it wasn't very noisy at night) down to the beach. The grounds are well kept and the atmosphere at the... More

We stayed in the Seafarer for three nights and enjoyed its quirky charm. The property is beautiful and has picnic benches, loungers and hammocks for use. And a few extremely friendly Squirrels. The staff are also extremely friendly and helpful, everyone from the reception (I assume the owner), the cleaner and the handy man. The fixings and furnishings are a... More

First of all the room needed a thorough cleaning. The sink was clogged in the bathroom. I had about 2 minutes of hot water while showering. My room was next to their supply room. I was woken up at around 7 am from a girl pulling everything out of the supply room & yelling at some guy about brooms. That... More

Our second time staying here and we had A GREAT TIME!! We were there the last of May and this time we took friends and family, our group rented 4 units by the water and we are thinking about making it a yearly trip and hope each year to get more to join us! The staff has always be helpful... More

Each room is a separate little building. The one we stayed in was clean but could have been much nicer with some thought. Someone put in new track lighting, but you either had to have it ALL on or ALL off which meant interrogation bright or dark. There was a nice deck but not even one plastic chair. The exterior... More

I just came from this place if i can call it a place, the grounds are beautiful but that is as far as it goes, the room we stayed in is disgusting it smelled like mold the sheet had some red stain on it very scornfull ,the tv forget it and you dont want to put feet on the floor... More

Had to post after reading some of these reviews. I have been staying at the Seafarer for a few years on and off. Was there almost every summer weekend in 2011. This place is one of the most laid back places to stay at. The managers are friendly and helpful. The grounds are kept beautiful. As for the rooms if... More