Beautiful grounds, nice clean rooms, and walking distance to just about everywhere. My husband and I shared a 2 bedroom suite with another couple. We took advantage of a special they offered for April - stay 2 nights, 3rd night free. Great value for what we were looking for. We didn't need an on site restaurant, a business center, any... more

Island City House is the perfect place if you want a small apartment instead of the common room that really only gives you a place to sleep. We stayed in the Carriage House facing Eaton St. on the second floor. The room had a large bathroom, nice kitchenette and the bed was tucked away in an alcove. Staying here was... more

We have stayed at various places on Key West for a few years now and were driven out of our previous fave by increased prices. We decided to give ICH a try based on the good reviews online and by the relatively reasonable prices and we were not disappointed. Our queen suite was lovely, if decorated in a manner (Victorian)... more

Looked forward to the drive from Miami after being on a Western Caribbean cruise. Unfortunately our Cozumel stop was changed to Key West because of the swine flu so we saw KW a day early! We drove back down the following day and stayed at the Island City House Hotel in the Old Town area. We wanted a small intimate... more

Great location,staff was wonderful.grounds well kept and the room were very nice. We were a group of 3 couples.... We would recommend to anyone. more

My husband and I enjoyed our stay. The walkways were surrounded by tropical plants and flowers and seemed like a quiet, perfect retreat. Unfortunately for us, we were surrounded by families with young children which made it pretty loud. It was completely our fault for not anticipating so many children since this is one of the few B&B's that allow... more

This is a very attractive hotel in lovely gardens but underneath the apparent laid back atmosphere is an uptight feel. For that reason I wouldn't recommend taking children. We felt very inhibited with ours and despite the fact they are generally well behaved and pretty nice kids we were on edge the whole time. The breakfast is poor. more

My husband, myself, and our friends stayed at the Island City House for 2 nights March 22-23. We had no problem checking in when our Key West ferry arrived at 11:30. My room was not ready but they gave me an upgrade to the Cigar House Suite 12 which was ready. It was a very nice 2 room suite. The... more

Stepping out of our room was like walking into a little jungle paradise. Breakfast was served in a courtyard garden with orchids hanging overhead. Even our bathroom was beautiful. The biggest downside: very creaky floors. Also, the streetside parking situation seemed annoying for those with cars. We had a large group spread over multiple rooms, one of which had a... more