We stayed at the Red Rooster over New Years. It was great. The room (#3) was large and clean. It was on the Truman side and we ate our breakfast our on our porch and watched the people go by. The pool was warm and clean. There could be more lounge chairs during the high season. We always had parking... more

My husband and I took a quick run down to the Keys from Miami for an overnight stay. Last year we stayed at the sister property, the Chelsea House and thought we could not be more pleased. Upon arrival we were escorted to every available room to choose one to our liking in the Red Rooster. The service and staff... more

My husband and I stayed here while we were in Key West to get married. The staff was very nice. The room was small and the furniture not at all brand new. I could have lived with everything (for the price) except the fact that I had to wear shoes constantly in the room. I stepped into the shower after... more

My wife and I spent 4 days and 3 nights in the Inn. The staff was incredible, the facilities and the grounds were immaculate! Make sure when you go to the keys, that if you don't stay here, you at least stop by and check it out. The appearance of these B&B's are outstanding. Red Rooster is by far one... more

Unfortunately we only had time to spend 1 night at this wonderful B&B. Friendly staff, very well maintained property, inviting, clean pool. Our room was luxurious, simply lovely, with a wonderful large balcony. Breakfast was hearty and versatile, served poolside. Private parking for most of the guests, otherwise in the street, but no problem. It was a good value and... more

Okay, our room was a little small and could have been better maintained around the edges - but then again, we were only paying a little over half what people at other guest houses were! This is an amazing place for such a low price! The grounds were picturesque, the pool refreshing, the breakfast each morning was wonderful, the fellow... more

If you understand island life, then you'll understand the Red Rooster. The rooms, pool and bathing area are perfect. You are down in the keys for island life, not the room. I've been staying at the Red Rooster for the last two years. I will continue to stay in an establishment which treats me like family and welcomes me with... more

First off, let me say that the negative reviews here gave me and my not-so-long-suffering boyfriend some pause -- so imagine our surprise when we discovered this lovely little inn so well-placed in Old Town. We were contacted three separate times before arriving -- once to confirm our reservation and deposit; a second time to touch base with us the... more

I never stayed there before but already had a bad experience. I reserved a hotel room for one day through hotel.com . Four days later I called the hotel to conform my reservation. A representative told me that there was no room booked under my name and they never booked for one day. I called hotel and canceled the room.... more