Excellent location, addicting sunrises, nice rooms and friendly staff. What do you need more? It is much better than all those 'poshy' resorts full of loud tourists. And you can have it for a really affordable price. Highly recommended! more

We had a wonderful time! When we first came in we had to go the office of the Yellowtail Inn. They have 3 hotels right next to each other. They were very helpful & gave us beach towels and a lot of great ideas of things to do. When we got to our cottage it was just like I pictured,... more

My wife and I stayed over the Thanksgiving holiday and had a fabulous time. We are seasoned travelers who usually stay at 5 star properties but decided this time to kick back in traditional Keys style. We enjoyed watching the sunrise every morning from the water front cabana while having our coffee that we made in our efficiency. The front... more

We were little uneasy getting reservations at Bonefish, due to previous reviews, but took advantage of their special (get 3rd night free) and were pleasantly surprised. Front Desk made us feel welcome from the very beginning (Lori is a bundle of information!) and accommodations were simple but comfortable and clean. I have traveled to the keys in the past and... more

I'm sorry I didn't know about Tripadvisor.com BEFORE we went to Bonefist Resort. This place is a dive, just like the other reviewers stated. We arrived Nov. 5 and left Nov. 5 2009. The room is filtly, Rm #312, mold and rust. The room is on a slant. The wood is rotted. The deck has rotted wood, a dead palm... more

Save your money, unless you have just gotten out of prison, that's the only thing I could compare this beat up old place to. Small, dirty, filthy beach area, broken down decks, dirty outdoor grill, dead palm trees and a foul odor in the rooms. It should be condemned. $20 bucks a night is too much! more

Bonefish Resort was very comfortable. It met our needs. It was clean and more affordable than others we checked into. You could swim, fish, sunbathe, swim in the water without going anywhere else. more

I went down to the Keys with 2 friends to visit another friend who is a dolphin trainer down there. On a budget, we chose Bonefish because it was relatively cheap, had a kitchen and two beds. In hindsight, paying a little more would have been worth it. There was mold growing in the picture frame in the "dining room"... more

My sister in law made the reservations on Expedia and thought we were getting a pretty good deal well she was WRONG. We first stayed in Key West seeing all the sights having never been to the Keys. We made our way back to the resort which is outside of Marathon by about 4-5 miles. We got to the Bonefish... more