I can't give a good rate to this place, I feel it's unfair towards other guests. I have to counterweight all these overstated ratings. There's nothing excellent/very good. The office is located in the twin structure (1.4 miles by car) so that when you arrive, you are greeted by a envelope taped on a window with your name on and... More

I would like to start by saying the people who have bad reviews of this place were obviously disgruntled about something other than this place. True, if you're looking for a "resort" style place, then this is not for you. This much more laid back and relaxing. Everything was exactly as advertised. The room was clean with fresh white linens... More

My husband and I spent three nights in January at the Banana Bay Club Beachside Villas. We loved our stay and would highly recommend this property. The reasons are: 1. Clean and comfortable rooms that are nicely decorated - Stayed in Villa 1 2. Convenient and free parking - Right outside the front door of our villa 3. Cozy accommodations... More

Me and my family have stayed at both properties and enjoyed each one. The waterside cottages were very quiet and relaxing. We loved the deck for fishing and just sitting and enjoying the view. The location of beachside was perfect. We were able to walk to the restaurants and the beach. Also the properties landscaping is beautiful. Heated pool and... More

I think this is a great price for a hotel that's right by the beach. However, we were really disappointed with our room. It was much smaller than the photo and the room did not seem well-maintained. There was build up around the sinks, the couch was very worn, the tiles were chipped etc. The bedroom also smelled a bit... More

My husband and I stayed here Valentines day weekend and it is very close to the beach and we appreciated it being on the quieter side of the key (away from Siesta Key Village and the bar scene). It is nice and clean, however it's definitely not any kind of luxury stay. Also if you are looking for peace and... More

When coming to Siesta Key..there is only 1 place to stay..or 2 actually..BOTH Banana Bay Club locations are wonderful!! My husband & 2 boys have stayed in both locations. The one on the lagoon is quiet & peacful. Nice little cottages. The beachside is lovely also with a variety of cottage choices and is just a short stroll to the... More

This place is fantastic. The accomodations were just as promised...GREAT!!! The place was immaculate. Gina has an unending smile and makes the place feel like home away from home. It was a great stay....just not long enough!

This is our 3rd year staying at Banana Bay Club. My husband and I (oh yeah, and dogs) love it here. We stay in Villa 4. It is perfect, has everything, stove, frig, etc. poolside deck, and front deck. Perfect little stroll to the beach. The location of the Villas is close to everything. The staff is wonderful, all is... More