My husband and I needed something affordable and wanted something on the water. This was the perfect place for us. It is a laid back resort that has a beautiful location. The beach was beautiful and we enjoyed sitting out in the evenings watching the sunset. We would definitely stay here again.

After reading the reviews on Atlantic Bay I thought it would be like the other simple, old-style Keys places we stay 2-3x each year, but it wasn't. First the room (Ocean view #2) was cleaned (as confirmed by the office manager) with a "de-odorizing" chemical which was so strong we could not remain in the room and none of the... More

We stayed at the Heron room at the Atlantic Bay resort from May 11th until May 17th 2013. Our housekeepers and the staff were all very friendly, and helpful. Our room had 2 small dorms fridges, and a sink and cook top. Room was very basic, could use a new mattress. We saw peacocks on the grounds every night, they... More

The Atlantic Bay ia a small resort located down a quiet side road on the Gullf side of the Overseas Highway. The grounds and pool are well maintained and very beautiful. We had the Carribean Beach Suite which whilst being somewhat basic was clean and had everything one could want including a fully equiped kitchen (who want to spend time... More

We really enjoyed our visit to this place. Our cottage was clean and spacious and we could sit out on a small deck and look down towards the beach. A highlight was sitting out on the beach, sipping wine and watching the sunset. We were quite pleased with the location as it meant a short trip to Key West. I... More

We booked the Atlantic Bay Resort because it was pretty much the only place available with a beach front when we planned for our trip. The Resort is really a Motel with some private bungalows, and yes it is located right on the water, with a small artificial beach and a small pool. As others have noted, the rooms (#18... More

This resort was recommended by a friend of my wifes and he was spot on. It is true that this resort has some age on it but it is filled w/ character. We stayed in room 16 which is the Tropical Suite. I think it's the best room on the property due to location/price/size. We would go hours without even... More

This is the cutest little motel you ever saw. Loved the greenery, made my Facebook profile pic our of the beautiful hibiscus I took a picture of outside our door. Their cozy little beach was nice to relax on. The only thing I might change is the mattresses, they were a bit on the old, hard side. Could do some... More

We stayed here for 2 nights and really liked it. The rooms are simple and not been updated in a while - and they could do with a new matrass. But for this price you don't expect a boutique hotel. Plus you get rewarded with a lovely little beach - that we had all to ourselves one day with a... More