It has been a year since we were at the Pickett House; it has taken that long for me to decide whether to tell the truth. We went to another nearby island this summer and stayed in an inn which looked to be similar on the www. They were very different. The Pickett House did not deliver what they promised... more

My wife and I spent 3 nights here for our first anniversary. We figured that the "Up-Island" B&B would be the quieter and more romantic than others. The Pickett House didn't disapoint!!! The B&B is perfectly located amid farms and meadows and is just down the street from Chilmark Market and a short bike ride from Menemsha (a nice litttle... more

I recently had the opportunity to stay at the quaintest little home on Martha's Vineyard. I had the most pleasant visit. Let me tell you about this home that is an "old vineyard style" home that has been marvelously done in antiques and with an eclectic style by its owner. She is a wonderful host and definately dedicated to perfection... more

July 27, 2007 My wife and I spent a week here in early July which is the second time we have stayed at The Pickett House. The first time was in July of 2002, before it was refurbished. It was very nice then but now it is outstanding. The owner, Elizabeth, is a most interesting and gracious hostess. Mornings, she... more

We booked the large, king-sized room at The Pickett House for 3 nights in July and were sorely disappointed, especially after reading the other reviews. For the $300-a-night pricetag, we expected a quiet, luxury retreat in one of the Vineyard's prettiest towns. Instead, we found a bed-and-breakfast located directly off a busy road and terribly lacking service. In fact, we... more

Five stars. On second thought make that six! The Pickett House is tucked away in a quiet corner of the Vineyard, "Up-Island". We found this home is meticulously cared for at this lovely retreat. Upon first stepping into the house we felt like we were home. Upon arrival the aroma of freshly baked cookies hovered in the entryway and dining... more

My wife and I recently had the pleasure of staying at this b + b for four wonderful days. This establishment offers three bedrooms on a beautiful piece of bucolic property. The bedroom that we stayed in downstairs was exceptionally well decorated with a Ralph Lauren bed set and plenty of room for us.It is conveniently located to the private... more

We left the kids and the mainland behind and travelled to the farther, quieter end of Martha's Vinyard. Chilmark is reminiscent of the Old Cape and this B&B, a farm house of 1700s vintage brought us further back in time. The owner was very gracious and we had a refrigerator for us and other guests to keep our sundries including... more

You have to look for this wonderful B&B. They gave us privacy, information about the island and made us feel very welcomed. We relaxed in a wonderful large room with a king sleigh bed. It was clean, cozy, decorated with high end furnishings, lovely flowers and quiet. The breakfast was fresh banana bread and fruit which was all we needed... more