Kelley House is historic-the building dates from the 1700's. But its rooms have all the amenities a 21st century traveler needs: very large and comfortably furnished, well-appointed bathrooms, extremely clean, very comfortable beds and linens, refrigerator, quiet, and a joy to stay in. The lobby has an inviting fire in the fireplace, with fresh, warm cookies in the evening and... More

My fiance and I stayed at the Kelley House this past weekend (June 1-3) due to the great reviews. However, we were less than impressed. I have never written a review for a place I have stayed until now. Upon arriving, we removed the bed comforter to find black hair everywhere. There were also dried blood stains on one of... More

After reading the comments of other travelers I must say--it appears that not much has changed since our visit in 1979!!! We only had reservations for one night-due to a nasty storm we were unable to return to Falmouth as all of the ferry boats were locked in port. The staff at the Kelly House were so wonderful and they... More

You are paying for location and that is about it. One of the previous reviews said it best, "uninspiring." The hotel was clean but was not up todate. The carpet through-out our room and parts of the hotel was stained and bordered on disgusting. It is an old noisy hotel. In our room we could hear ever step taken on... More

Not having stayed elsewhere on MV, I don't know how this place compares with other establishments. We stayed for one night during shoulder season with a reasonable price. We had a large corner room on the second floor. The decoration is outdated and the bathroom needs a makeover. The mattress was a bit saggy. We did like how bright the... More

We recently spent the weekend in the Chappy House with our dog. The location was fantastic and super convenient to the downtown area shops and restaurants. The room was perfect for us and very pet-friendly without it being a "pet" room (ie. no smells, stains, etc...). We were on the 1st floor of the Chappy House and it was very... More

This was a family trip - 4 adults (kids being 24 and 26). We wanted to explore historic, quaint Martha's Vineyard over the Easter holiday weekend. This was off season for MV and we got a very good price for a very good room. I spent a lot of time reviewing Trip Advisor for the perfect Inn, but did not... More

I have been to many places in MV over the decades. Looking for a place to chill out for my family after a tragedy. I read many reviews before decision. Charlotte who had exc. recommendations did her job superbly. No request was overlooked, room near lobby was so peaceful fire going in lobby every day was most welcoming. Karen, a... More

A totally bias review here. Since 2001 the Kelley House has been my summer vacation spot. My family has gotten to know the staff as they've gotten to know us. I really don't know if I get special treatment. I watch interaction with all guests and the special treatment is given to all. In the past twelve years we've incorporated... More