The Edgartown Inn is a beautiful property, right in the heart of Edgartown. My husband and I stayed there for two nights for a wedding weekend, and as a result of the reviews, we specifically requested the third floor. Our experience was lovely. We were away from the hustle and bustle of people going on the first floor and the... more

We arrived at the Edgartown Inn in early August on a late summer afternoon to find the entire Inn smelling from the busy breakfast crowd that morning. Our run down room on the second floor that wasn’t even above the kitchen reeked of molasis. When we asked the Innkeeper for a change she told us that the smell would go... more

My husband and I recently visited Martha's Vineyard for the first time, and stayed at the Edgartown Inn. It was really a very nice experience. The location of the inn was perfect; It wasn't right in the loud center of town, but it was only about a two minute walk away. Our room was on the second floor, very clean... more

I stayed here thinking I had this excellent value based on a review in Frommer's. It might have been one of the cheaper places to stay in Martha's Vineyard but it was no value. Why oh why can't these B and B's spring for a decent queen sized mattress when their rooms can easily accomodate them? The double mattress was... more

The Edgartown Inn is a most pleasant place to stay in Martha's Vineyard. The location is right in the center of the town but I found the room to be quiet. I was given an especially large, front room which faces the water so I awoke every day for a week to a beautiful view. The manager, Sandy, is delightful... more

We had a great stay at the Edgartown Inn in Edgartown, MA on Martha's Vineyard. Martha's Vineyard should be proud to have such a fine Inn and Innkeeper catering to the needs of its tourists. We stayed there October 3rd and 4th and couldn't have been happier. The breakfast room is filled with happy talk and laughter from appreciative guests.... more

We had an outstanding visit to Martha's Vineyard--our first of many that we have since experienced--with our stay at the Edgartown Inn. The Inn was exquisitely decorated and immacuately kept. Our room overlooking Water Street and the harbor was gorgeous and spacious. The Edgartown Inn is definitely worth the money--it's centrally located in historic Edgartown and the service is exceptional!!... more