My husband and I stay at the Edgartown Inn every year and stay in the vary room the Wanderingbostonian stayed in. WE LOVE IT! Although its probably not for everyone, its very affordable and the reservation staff always have made it clear that you are sharing a public rest room. The rooms are very clean and comfortable and the staff... more

This is the worst "hotel" I have ever stayed in. We were in an outhouse next to a road leading to a ferry terminal; traffic began at 7am outside our window and lasted all day. Bed was uncomfortable and the carpet was moldy, not good for people with allergies or asthma. Worst part of our very short stay was that... more

We came to Edgartown inn after a few days on the island and were lucky to find nice clean rooms and an amazing staff always friendly and helpful. We recommend this inn with the cozy porch and the relaxed atmosphere and most importantly the great location within walking distance to everything. more

A friend and I stayed at this wonderful old inn for just a night. We were lucky enough to have it recommended by the man who runs the shop where the bus lets you off and we were not disappointed. Granted we were lucky that the room on the top floor was available. It had an antique sofa wonderfully positioned... more

The Edgartown Inn is the perfect place to stay on Martha's Vineyard. The rooms are clean and the location is perfect. You can walk every where, shops, restaurants, Edgartown Harbor and Edgartown Lighthouse. It's only a short drive or bike ride to South Beach! I would highly recommend it! more

Just got back from a great stay at the Edgartown Inn. The location is perfect...2 blocks to everything in town but just out of town enough so it is somewhat quiet. The porch is the best part...filled with wicker chairs and loungers so you can relax and watch the world go by! It was one of the few places that... more

The Edgartown Inn is a beautiful property, right in the heart of Edgartown. My husband and I stayed there for two nights for a wedding weekend, and as a result of the reviews, we specifically requested the third floor. Our experience was lovely. We were away from the hustle and bustle of people going on the first floor and the... more

We arrived at the Edgartown Inn in early August on a late summer afternoon to find the entire Inn smelling from the busy breakfast crowd that morning. Our run down room on the second floor that wasn’t even above the kitchen reeked of molasis. When we asked the Innkeeper for a change she told us that the smell would go... more

My husband and I recently visited Martha's Vineyard for the first time, and stayed at the Edgartown Inn. It was really a very nice experience. The location of the inn was perfect; It wasn't right in the loud center of town, but it was only about a two minute walk away. Our room was on the second floor, very clean... more