A fine location overlooking the water and lighthouse and just a 5 minute pleasant stroll past the captains houses to the main street, restaurants and nearest bus stop. My room was I believe the most basic and located in one of the various outbuildings but still came in at a fairly hefty price ($265) but then this is beautiful Edgartow.... more

We stayed at the Harbor View Hotel in Edgartown on Martha's Vineyard the early part of September 2008 and had a terrific stay!!Everything, from the initial booking, the check-in, the quality of the overnight room and housekeeping staff to the check-out was first-class. Easy access to downtown Edgartown, great ocean view. Would highly recommend this property to anyone. Can be... more

Just returned from three days stay in the Jason Luce cottages at the Harbor View - we had #22 but I recommend #23 which is identical but has a view over the lawn at the front. The hotel is in the middle of a mega million dollar renovation and will close for the next phase in mid-October (there is no... more

Fantastic hotel. Common areas are newly renovated. Great location near the center of Edgartown (~10 min walk). Amazing views. Very friendly staff. ...and the hotel restaurant was one of the best that we tried on the island (Water St. is the name). Only drawback was that the renovations of the common areas did not seem to fully carry through to... more

We were a small part of 17 rooms reserved for a wedding of a local resident. We had 3 rooms for our family and were able to view a cottage pent house. Without exception, we had a wonderful experience. Our young adult sons (23-29) thought the location and amenities were perfect and we(the parents) agree. The location was perfect, the... more

Pros: We had a 2-bedroom suite that was large and nicely laid out, and the view from the hotel's front porch is indeed lovely. The staff is unfailingly pleasant. Cons: The Harbor View is a pleasant hotel but calling itself a resort and charging the prices it does, it feels more like a ripoff. The website presents it as a... more

We stayed at the Harbor View Hotel for two nights and wished we stayed longer. The hotel is centrally located; it's a short drive from Vineyard Haven and Oak Bluffs and a 10 minute walk to the shops and restaurants in Edgartown. We traveled with our young son and found the hotel to be family friendly. We had a room... more

While the price tag was hefty -- it was absolutely worth it. The room we had was the size of a suite with a stunning view of the Edgartown harbor. The staff were friendly and courteous, and enjoyed lounging on the veranda with a cocktail from Henry's (the Harbor View's casual fare bar and restaurant). Would definitely recommend it to... more

The Harbor View has a practically perfect location -- overlooking the mouth of Edgartown harbor. I mean, there is a lighthouse right out front. How great is that? They have a great lobby -- very comfortable -- and a fantastic porch where I could sit for hours. It was somewhat early in the season and the staff seemed to be... more