I read all the reviews and booked a cottage for a 3 night stay. I was so excited! It looked great! WRONG! Our cottage was so rundown and dirty.Gouges in the walls,dirty appliances, dishes & counters, moldy tiles in the bathroom, dirty carpet & couch. Broken screen doors& fireplace screen. Moldy outdoor furniture and they short sheeted our bed. Trash... more

We had visited Martha's Vineyard two years before and fell in love with the fishing village Menemsha. The laid back atmosphere and quaint setting drew us in. We saw the Inn on our way to the beach and vowed to return for a stay. At first glance, it may seem pricey for the rustic accommodations, but this is island vacationing... more

It may be an odd thing to say, but the harbor bell that clangs off Menemsha Bight downhill from The Menemsha Inn is the reason we love staying at the Inn. The bell’s purpose is to warn and guide boats entering the harbor, but uphill, from the Inn, it sounds gently and calms. In the distance its dulled, lonely, solitary... more

We just returned from 4 nights in a cottage at the Menemsha Inn and Cottages and though the setting was beautiful it was certainly NOT worth the money. When we checked in we were told that if we wanted bikes they could "maybe find a couple in the cellar that weren't in too bad a shape." When we got to... more

I loved the Mennemsha Inn we stayed in a average room for one night that was very nice and moved to a suite in the main building on the 2nd floor.. I am now from Florida and as the sunsets the sunshines right into the 2nd floor suites. (((The view was to die for))) After cutting up some cheese's opening... more

As first time visitors to the Vineyard we couldn't have been happier with our stay. After spending 2 nights in Edgartown we traveled "Up-Island" to the Menemsha Inn. It was serenely exquisite. We stayed in a Carriage House room that was lovely and very comfortable with a deck that offered an uninterrupted view of the country side and ocean beyond.... more

Beautiful location, but the Inn is poorly run. Twice, we discovered that we had no hot water in our room. Although the problem was quickly resolved both times, we were rather disappointed with how the Inn's staff handled the problem. For example, on neither instance when we informed the front desk of the problem were we ever told "Sorry about... more

All I can say is THERE IS NO A/C! No AC in the middle of summer in New England is unbearable. I appreciate the desire for 'rustic', but come on. It's the 21st century. I even brought an extra fan from home anticipating the heat. It wasn't enough. Room in the Carriage House was large, bathroom was smallish, dingy-looking. Most... more

This is a wonderful place. Please don't tell anyone!! Our double room in the Tea House was not fancy, but very comfortable. The balcony is the draw and it was extremely difficult to decide to move from there. The grounds, the view and the location can't be beat. So wonderfully quiet and relaxing. We had a great breeze and didn't... more