Considering the fact that this hotel is an effective 30-min train ride from Manhattan, it's a bargain really. The staff are friendly, rooms are OK, breakfast -included in price- is decent and a shuttle takes you to and from Newark Penn Station (where you catch NJT or PATH to Manhattan). However, I was given a rather shabby room located just... more

Large, clean rooms. Breakfast was ok, but not super. Train is only 5 min. walk, so you don't have to wait for the shuttle that leaves every 30 min. Good for visiting NYC if you're not going there for the nightlife. more

Fine room at a good rate ($80 11/09) Close to Newark Penn Station. The room initially smelled of disinfectant but that went away. Pickup from the airport was not quick. Keep calling back until they pick you up. It's a great deal near Manhattan but it isn't 20 minutes. More like 40. Easy to get into the city and the... more

We are from Montreal drove to NJ/NYC for few days of vacations.We first stopped at Woodbury Outlet and spend hours of shopping. We checked in around 5PM. As I have read in the previous reviews I was not expecting a superb service. We were four inlcuding my 2 yr old son with luggages and shopping bags. At the reception I... more

My cousin and I stayed here for 7 nights because we got a ridiculously cheap rate for the hotel. The purpose of our trip was to visit NYC and, based off of the reading we did, it seemed like an easy commute from Newark Penn Station (NPS) to New York Penn Station and back. I also managed to miss the... more

I stayed with my husband 8 days mid-Sept to visit New York City. Overall, Robert Treat was a good hotel for the price and it wasn’t a lot of extra effort to commute from New Jersey to New York everyday. Breakfast and easy transfer to airport compensated for the commute required to go to New York. We encountered 2 issues... more

I stayed here for 3 nights whilst visiting New York, as a cheaper option than staying in Manhattan. The half-hourly hotel shuttle bus is reliable, and serves Newark Penn Station and also Newark airport, and they pick you up from the train station if you ring. The train journey (either on the NJ Transit or Path) is less than 30... more

I was a guest at this hotel from Thursday, Nov. 5th until this morning, Nov.8th....although the rooms were satisfactory, we were very unhappy at not being able to receive Fox Cable News on TV. We like to keep informed on current happenings and I cannot understand why it was not available. In fact,the TV selection, in general, was very poor.... more

Hello Folks, Last weekend I stayed at the Robert Treat and I had a pleasant experience. I had no problem with customer service as others have noted. The gentleman that checked me in was polite and courteous and gave me a beautiful room with a view of the park! I loved the decor of the room, especially the tall ceilings,... more