We just returned from a spontaneous overnight at the Coffey House & need to concur with all these other glowing reviews. We were hesitant as every other place was booked (peak summer weekend) but they had availability & we were wondering what was wrong with it. The truth is: nothing is wrong with it! They just don't market it the... More

The best thing about Coffey House is the couple who own and run it -- Ellie & Rick Coffey. Although they hail from different professions, you'd think they'd been in the hospitality business forever. They're welcome is warm, their service impeccable and their breakfasts out of this world (they're both avid and excellent cooks!). Running a close second in terms... More

Was at Coffey House last weekend (June 30th-July1st, 2012). Can't wait to go back--wonderful, peaceful, relaxing place with beautifully appointed rooms--immaculate, quiet. The owners, Ellie and Rick Coffey are the perfect hosts, discreet and hospitable--you can tell they love what they do and they're wonderful at it! The house dates from the 19th century and while the aesthetic respects the... More

We just came back from Coffey house and We can only describe it in one word...FABULOUS!!! My wife and I decided the last minute to go the winery in Northfork L.I. .We never went to a B&B before but always wanted to do it.We called the Coffey House and luckily they had 1 room left.Upon arriving there we were greated... More

To say we enjoyed our relaxing getaway from the city at the Coffey House would be an understatement. My wife wanted to pick out days to come back for next year before we even left the place! But I digress. The inn itself was immaculate. As soon as you step in, you can just feel the departure from NYC (a... More

We booked the Coffey House as a last minute get away for Memorial Day weekend. What an absolute delight! We took a chance and had the best weekend ever and it was all because of Ellie and Rick. The house is immaculate, the rooms are prestine, and the food was heavenly. We loved our time there and the gorgeous backyard.... More

What an exquisite gem! Ellie and Rick Coffey are wonderful hosts. They were laid back, welcoming and created fantastic food. Ellie’s wonderful baking and Rick’s culinary touch made for a delicious 3 course breakfast. The house is warm and inviting while having impressive modern features such as remote controlled fire places and heated floors in some rooms. The suite we... More

Coffey House is a lovely, well-appointed, and spotless B&B in a beautiful area, a few minutes' drive to the charming North Fork town of Greenport, Long Island. Ellie and Rick Coffey are awesome hosts--delightful people who really know how to make their guests feel welcome and well attended to, yet are very respectful of their guests' privacy. We had the... More

This is one of the nicest places I have ever stayed at. Ellie and Rick did it right. Everything from the gorgeous house and tastefully done rooms to the spacious backyard and outstanding deck, this B&B was amazing. And the food was something else! I would definitely go back to Long Island just to stay here again! If you are... More