Our stay at the Bartlett House was really great. Jack and Diane have done a wonderful job in renovating the inn – I had not been there in many years. The décor is in such great taste, the rooms are really, really comfortable, and Jack and Diane are gracious innkeepers. They know the area like the back of their hand,... More

The Bartlett House Inn, as advertised, is nicely situated in Greenport, convenient to downtown and restaurants, on the road toward the wineries and quite close to the Shelter Island ferry. We had a very pleasant stay in a nicely appointed, modestly sized room, albeit with a quite small bath. The inn owners are cheerful and great hosts. The inn grounds... More

This is a beautiful, historic property owned and operated by a lovely couple. The breakfast is fabulous - variety of choices, a fresh quiche and plethora of dishes every day. Make sure you look at the rooms on line because they are all different and vary substantially in size. It is pricey but is similar to other places in town.... More

The Bartlett House is a beautiful grand home that is comfortable and inviting. It is located a few blocks from the center of town on the main street. Our room (#7) is a large, beautifully decorated room in the front of the house with a separate sitting area and walk in closet. I got a peak of several other rooms... More

Perfect, exquisitely furnished; fantastic food -- owners are supremely hospitable. Made our daughter's wedding weekend even better. Regards to Jack & Dianne More

Cheerful and helpful owners, lavishly decorated and immaculately clean. Ideal location with a short walk to the town's amenities yet (just) far enough from them to offer some quietude. Very nice breakfast. More

This is our 3rd time staying at the Bartlett House in the past 6 years. Each time we've been treated great, the breakfast buffet was perfect and the hosts, Diane and Jack, couldn't have been more accommodating. Each time we stayed in a different room, we loved all of them. The rooms were beautiful and the beds were comfortable, and... More

We were looking for a restful, beautiful place to spend our first non-staycation vacation in over twenty years and we were lucky enough to find the Bartlett House Inn. Actually, lucky isn't a strong enough word-- blessed is more like it. Bartlett House is a sumptuously decorated restored 19th century home that felt like OUR home almost as soon as... More

The Bartlett House Inn is a diamond in the rough! It is absolutely flawless in all aspects, from the perfect cleanliness to the charming owners (Jack and Diane) to the decor. Although we stayed only one night, it was a stay to remember. Diane's breakfast spread was fantastic and our room was decorated wonderfully. We booked the Bartlett House as... More