While I resist the temptation to pile on - I have to agree with the previous reviewer. We found the Black Sheep Inn provided much less then we expect in an excellent B&B in this price range. The first - and I mean very first - experience we had walking in the door was to be asked for our credit... more

Although the Black Sheep Inn is an interesting historic establishment near the quaint Finger Lakes town of Hammondsport, we won’t stay there again. When we return to this region, we’ll look for more welcoming establishments in New York's premier wine district. Many are as conveniently located to this area’s outstanding wineries as is the Black Sheep Inn. If what you... more

We stayed here for one night during a first time trip to the Finger Lakes over the Columbus Day week-end. This unique home has been lovingly restored by Marc and Debbie and we enjoyed viewing the photo albums that chronicle the years of work. Our room, Younglove, was comfortable and the second floor common area with the beautifully painted cupola... more

We've stayed at the Black Sheep Inn twice and will absolutely return again. Debbie and Marc have restored the gorgeous (octagonal!) house to immaculate condition and decorated it in a warm and unfussy manner. The bedrooms are comfortable and spacious (we've stayed in the biggest room and the smallest room and have seen the others and they all feel well-proportioned),... more

We stayed at the Black Sheep Inn because we were looking for a B&B in the Finger Lakes where we would not feel drowned in Victorian decor. Thankfully - we made the right choice in that respect. The decor is classic and comfortable. We stayed in the Younglove room. Nice size, lovely bathroom (great shower). We found Debbie to be... more

Must disagree with previous posters. Stayed at Black Sheep based upon favorable ratings here. Found the place a bit cluttered. Chose it over other locations due to the fact that many Keuka accommodations do not provide air conditioning. When asked to turn the central air on, hostess demurred, stating that "it was cool" which was not the case. Room was... more

My wife and I were planning a weekend trip to the Finger Lakes to celebrate our honeymoon, however we ended up waiting last minute to book. We wanted somewhere that we could make special in the hopes that we can return regularly. Initially we were planning to stay somewhere on Lake Cayuga but had trouble finding any vacant accomodations that... more

We were looking for a quiet place to stay during the weekend of our daughter's graduation from Alfred University and chose Black Sheep based on several of the Trip Advisor reviews. It turned out to be a wonderful choice. We (and all guests) were welcomed with our names on signs on the entry porch. Debbie showed us around the house... more

First night back after an awesome weekend with Debbie and Marc, innkeepers at Black Sheep Inn. Everything was outstanding, from the first phone contact to the pleasant late arrival. Small touches to make you feel welcome and the care that they put into running a this deserving 5 star establishment. The other guests were very friendly and hated to leave... more