My best friend's sister booked a suite at the Scribner Hollow Lodge as part of a birthday present to her sister. We were going to the TAP festival and were looking for a nice hotel within walking distance of Hunter Mountain. This is not remotely what we got. What we got was a delapidated, 70's lodge, complete with what appeared... more

If this hotel cost about $50 a night, I would not be writing a negative review. But the outrageous thing is that it cost almost $300 a night when we stayed there last weekend. We stayed in a tiny room with very little for amenities. We were told the room slept 3 comfortably. There was a full size bed and... more

My fiancee and I were in search of a reception location for our Autumn 2008 wedding. Scribner Hollow was first on our list of possibilities. We booked an overnight stay in February, and were totally thrilled! We were warmly welcomed by the Lodge owner and shown to our room. Our room was spacious, and tastefully appointed in Adirondack style. It... more

scribner hollow was supposed to be the only "deluxe" hotel in hunter so i booked a $316 "suite" with a fireplace for an extra $30. What i got was a shoe box of a room, the fireplace is about 2 feet from the bed and i couldn't see how you could use it in such a small room. i imm... more

We went there for my wifes birthday, big mistake ! upon arriving the driveway was all mud and huge craters. The hotel staff did not show us to the room just gave us keys and directions. The room was musky and smelled like dirty armpits..it was pretty clean though. The dinner was okay but the staff in the dining room... more

I recently went to Scribner Hollow in October for their Fall Harvest Wine Dinner. I decided to stay overnight at the hotel. We arrived and were graciously welcomed to the property and shown to our room. The hotel has a very warm comforting feel to it when we arrived. The property well maintaned and tastefully decorated. The feeling of a... more

I just returned form a conference at The Scribner Hollow Lodge and now I am looking at my calendar for my next free weekend. The atmosphere was spectacular, the views were sensational, the restaurant was beautiful, the food was as close to perfection as one could come. Every member of the staff we had contact with was warm and gracious.... more

I was surprised by the negative reviews I find of this place. All perfectly clean as far as ou room went. Didn't check out the pool, though. Spacious, comfortable room. Good dinner, included in room price. (Drinks charged extra, though.) Had the bacon-wrapped scallop and shrimp appetiser and double duck entree (breast quarter was advertised but I was served a... more

Just returned from a very pleasant 2 night stay at this resort in the Catskill mountains. Hated to leave. Went on a weekday, found it not busy at all, but none of the service was cut back. Bar was open, dining room done up in linens and crystal, pools sparkling, room clean, and staff pleasant and helpful. The room was... more