Was there with a group of over 60 friends had the place to our selves and had a fantastic time. Food was good and staff were very friendly. more

We were treated like friends, not strangers, during our stay. This is a classic mountain lodge. The view of the mountains was awesome. The suite was very cozy and well maintained by the staff. Also, there was always enough wood for the fireplace. The entire staff from the front desk, through the lounge and into the restaurant was courteous and... more

The owners and staff treated us like relatives that we've known for many years. They were willing to go out of their way to make sure that we had a most pleasant weekend. The room was great and the view was amazing. The food was delicious, gourmet style - from breakfast to dinner. The indoor pool and sauna felt like... more

It's laughable that this hotel is described as "deluxe." After traveling almost 4 hours from NYC, we were shocked to find that accommodations were rickety, stained and cheap. The most amazing attribute of this place is its website-- a marvel of marketing bull. Keep in mind that pictures are worth a thousand words and you will be unable to find... more

My husband and I spent 3 night here for our 3rd wedding anniversary and it was the perfect getaway. The staff were extremely nice and were very eager to accomodate all of our needs. The room was beautiful with a view to die for. The restaurant was absolutely amazing, the service outstanding and the food was incredible. Their steak and... more

We arrived at the Scribner Hollow Lodge with certain expectations based upon statements included in their website. What they fail to tell you is that the hotel has not been renovated in decades, the common rooms are unheated and the rooms are incredibly drafty with a radiator that gives you a choice of very hot or cold...no middle comfort. The... more

The Scribner Hollow Lodge is the a great place if you want to enjoy a friendly family atomsphere. Both Kate and Guy Chirico really know how to make a person feel at home. I work for Cerebral Palsy Associations of New York State and I took (8) eight mutiple handicapped individuals for a summer vacation. The service both from staff... more

My husband and I celebrated our wedding at Scribner Hollow on Columbus Day weekend, 2008. It was a second wedding for both of us, and our desire was for an intimate, special celebration for family and a handful of friends, and it was. From the beginning planning stages until the day we left, our special event was nothing but perfect.... more

Spent a wonderfull weekend with good friends. The Restaurant was one of the better dining experiences I have had in a long time. The staff from the front desk to the lounge area were fun, hospitable, and cheerful- everyone makes you feel like an old friend. There is no need to leave the property, everything you need is right there!... more