The motel is a bit on the older side but is kept very clean. Some of the rooms are also very cute. Not too far from the wineries either. Pleasant stay nonetheless. The single double bed room has an electric fireplace along with some open space for a small party.

Nothing fancy, but totally adequate and clean. As would be expected at a place that allows dogs and is priced so reasonably, there weren't any extra frills, but everything worked and was as described on the web site. We stayed in #12 of the Treman Lodge section of the hotel and the room was big and had a large window... More

We never expect 5 star since we travel with our dog. This was great as it had a fenced in dog play area. The motel was just fine for being pet friendly but maybe a little over-priced for November. My biggest complaint was the uncomfortable bed. It was hard and lumpy. I love a firm mattress but I awoke every... More

Went there for an overnight stopover on a multi-day road trip. Seems to be geared towards the dog lovers crowd, with dog playpens and all. We did not have any pets with us. Rooms are exactly as described and pictured on the motel's website: older style but very clean and spacious. The place was generally quiet in the evening and... More

This hotel had a retro vibe to it, sort of Norman Bates-ish but in a really good way. I loved it. The grounds were nice & the fireflies a bonus. The location was a bit far from Ithaca but I liked the more rural setting next to Buttermilk Falls Park. The room was very clean. The bed was a bit... More

My husband and I stayed at Grayhaven Motel in Ithaca, NY last summer, and have already booked our stay there again for our vacation in August. If you are going to Ithaca to play on the internet in your Swanky hotel room, don't stay at Grayhaven. But. . . if you are going to Ithaca to do things in and... More

First of all, this is not a B&B - I don't know why it's classified as such in Tripadvisor. Also, please note my rating is for and old style local motel. Please don't try to compare it to an upscale hotel or a chain hotel - it really doesn't compare favorably. Having said that, here are my comments. The hotel... More

I stayed here while my horse was at Cornell. Very quaint and comfortable though. The furnishings are outdated, but we stayed in the room with 2 double beds, and the beds were super comfy. I brought a small fan, which drowned the noise of any traffic that other reviews may mention, but didn't notice much traffic on the road anyway?... More

Did a tour of Cayuga Lake wineries.Gorgeous area.Ihaca itself is a great place.Grayhaven motel is not.Fan vent in bathroom filthy.Cobwebs and dead bugs in window. Carpet had an old stale smell.But the absolute worst was the mattress.Rock hard and old.I was so stiff the next morning it hurt.Stay away from this place.I wish we did.