I really love staying in unique places, especially historic. i've stayed at the rogues' harbor inn several times over the past few years- usually in room 6 or 2. i love the charm of the old woodwork and pressed tin ceilings. the rooms are lovely without being overdone. the staff is friendly and helpful without being fussy. on my last... more

The room was cute and cozy, the staff were very nice and helpful, and the burgers--seriously amazing. I hadn't planned on that aspect, but if you stay here, order a burger for dinner with a nice bottle of red! more

We found the Inn to be rundown and the room was not kept up to par. While it was 'clean', we would not call it 'immaculate'. The slanty floors and crooked windows are quaint, but the windows let in a terrible draft that literally blew the plastic sheeting away -- placed there, I'm sure, to keep out the cold. They... more

The staff is certainly friendly but that is where my praise for the property ends. I do not have outlandish standards. If I have a clean room I can be happy almost anywhere. Our room was not clean. It clearly had not been vacuumed. There was visible dirt on the floor, dead houseflies, and dust on everything from the lamp... more

We thoroughly enjoyed our stay at the Rogue's Harbor Inn. The food was excellent and reasonably priced. The room was comfortable and clean. The cranberry scones at breakfast were fantastic. more

My brother, myself , and our spouses decided to take a vacation in the Finger Lakes of NY and looked on-line at the b&b options on the Ithaca Chamber of Commerce website. We liked the website for the Rogue's Harbor Inn and decided to make reservations to spend a few nights there, selecting two rooms for two nights each. When... more

We were in town for a wedding and chose the Rogue's Harbor B&B quite last minute. The room was fine, and the bed comfortable. I really appreciated that the hotel owner wanted to conserve resources (by not changing the towels/sheets every night), but I did find the roll of brown paper towels in the shared bath to be contradictory to... more

My wife and I had a fabulous anniversary get away at the Rogue's Harbour Inn. We thoroughly enjoyed the room which was comfortable and blended modern ammenities with old time charm. The restaurant downstairs was terrific and affordable. All of the staff were friendly and helpful. We hope to go back sometime. more

We had a family reunion here using 6 of the seven rooms. Breakfast and planned family dinner were excellent. Rooms were very comfortable. We had a great time. more