Long Island in general tends to be overpriced, and this was no exception. The room was quaint and did include an ihome, which the kids loved, but the decor seemed kind of old. The indoor pool was small but nice. We did not get to take advantage of any outdoor amenities (are there any?) due to the weather, but when... more

The room was beautiful however the bathroom was barely functional. You could get into the bathroom if you maneuvered yourself around the door. It was not decorated at all and for some reason had lighting that was only bright after a few minutes. The tub was a nice extra long soaking tub, and the shower had a rainfall shower head.... more

This place is not even close to looking as nice as the pictures online. Very rude reception, arrived at 2:00 , they assured me to be back by 3 and they will have room ready, 4:00 PM and was not ready with no apology , dirty path room, noisy you can hear every move from the room above you. Just... more

Our wedding on August 29,2009 was perfect! Everything was done beautifully! We could not have asked for better service.My guests raved about the whole affair-including all the food, and your staff.Pam and Alex Cave,the wedding coordinator,was wonderful! Our guests who stayed the weekend were pleased with the accommodations as well. Hurricane Danny and all-it could not have been a more... more

The Montauk Yacht Club's website makes their resort out to something that we felt it was not. We were disappointed in the quality of the renovated room. We were disappointed in the staff. Not friendly, not welcoming, not helpful. The events they spoke of on the website that they do, family movie on the grass, maragritaville night...did not happen. I... more

We recently had our wedding at the Montauk Yacht Club on August 8th, 2009. Everything I envisioned my wedding to be came true! Throughout our wedding day, everyone at the Montauk Yacht Club made sure everything ran smoothly. From the moment I walked into the bridal suite in the morning, to taking pictures in the afternoon with my soon to... more

@ $500 the cheapest room, I think you should expect a minimum of service. - Newly decorated room are nice but you can hear people speaking from the left/right and upper room! - Staff does not intend to serve you and was many times rude. We kept asking for beach towels all the week end (they were short of it... more

I've been a long time observer of and visitor to the Montauk Yacht Club. They seem to have hit their stride with a redone dining concept and redone rooms. I've been there for several soirees of late and I'm really impressed. Hope to stay there in September for a weekend fishing for striped bass in Montauk! more

My wife and I were very impressed with the renovated and refreshed Montauk Yacht Club when we stayed for 3 days and 2 nights this summer. The newly refreshed rooms are light, bright, elegantly accessorized and very comfortable. MYC's staff is beautifully attired, friendly and well informed. Although the weather was spotty, we found our stay very enjoyable and were... more