We stayed there based on pictures of the place. My husband thought it looked quaint. The rooms are very old and extremely small. We had to leave our small suitcase by the exit door to get to the bathroom. There is nowhere to put ANYTHING. The bathroom is so small the toilet is right up against the tub, you can't... More

I recently stayed at the Pine Hill Arms Hotel with a few friends as we were traveling through the Catskill area - unfortunately, none of us checked the reviews (more on that in a moment). We based our decision to stay there on the photos of the rooms on the website and the reasonable price ($80 per night). The rooms... More

We spent the weekend there very recently to ski at nearby Belleayre Mountain. We checked out their website first and looked at all the photos of their attractive rooms. Don't let yourself get fooled. The rooms look nothing like that. First of all, there are no bulbs stronger than about 25 watts, so EVERYTHING is dark and dingey looking. The... More

We have never stayed at the Arms as we have a weekend home nearby but always have dinner there when we are here. Valerie and Robert Konefal have always been very gracious to us and we share a love of "retrievers" - theirs, two labs and ours, a "golden". We can't say enough positive things about the wait staff, especially... More

We reserved a room in mid-January with Valerie, who on the phone was very rushed and brusque and unclear in her explanation of how various things work, such as the deal to buy lift tickets through her hotel (I'm a journalist at the Wall Street Journal, so probably an ok judge on clarity). We arrived in the hotel that morning... More

I had a great time staying the Pine Hill Arms -stayed there for the Charlie Daniels concert at Belleyare and there he was having dinner two tables away in the Arms restaurant. Can’t beat that! Food’s great, bar is fun rooms clean but sparse. No elevators or room service - think country.

Attending a Charlie Daniels Band concert some weeks ago, I found a marvelous B & B in the town of Pine Hill. I never expected the Pine Hill Arms to provide such wonderful accomodations so convenient to the venue. While the restaurant was outstanding, the entire staff was friendly and particularly attentive. The owner, Robert Konefal took extra pains to... More

This hotel should be considered if you are in the area of Bellayre Mountain for a weekend of skiing. The staff is very courteous and super accommodating. The place is a flashback hotel, antiquated, but charming.. It is warm and relaxing. It has a beautiful restaurant on site. Terrific breakfast and dinner. This place is a hidden gem for a... More

We felt right at home in this historic hotel located in the heart of the Catskills. We arrived in the late afternoon and were greeted like old friends and shown to our lovely, quaint room. Dinner was wonderful. Our waitress was pleasant and efficient. The cook even came out to greet us and ask how our meals were. I like... More