This place is a friggin JOKE! I was appalled at the condition and quality of this hotel, especially given the outrageous prices they charge. The rooms are atrocious! The tennis court is a lawsuit waiting to happen. Even the location sucks. Despite being close to town I had to listen to construction across the street every morning/day. This place rapes... more

The only thing going for this place is that It is in a great location but everything else about it is bad. It is old and in desperate need of a major overhaul. The bath mat was moldy and the room smelled. The comforter for the bed was ancient. It was worn out and looked really bad. If you need... more

RUN! Don't stay at this overpriced dump! For almost $200 nite we got a dark, dreary, dirty, dingy, moldy smelling room - that the staff never cleaned or freshened up even once during our 2 night stay. Cruddy old rug, dusty old curtains. Quilts & bed linens, long since needing replacement. Slider screen barely slides, patio tacky w/ mismatched furniture.... more

Writing this to help my fellow travellers. If you are looking for a clean, fairly up-to-date, reasonable place to lay your head in Sag Harbor, run to something else; this is NOT it! I don't know what happened to this place, as I had stayed there in the past (about 5 years ago) and had multiple great experiences, but the... more

We would have been satisfied with a comfortable room in a place that was accurately represented by their website. Instead it was clear that the photographer had the talent to hide the blemishes and wrinkles. What we found was the equivalent of a cut-rate motel off Route 66, where a cross country trucker needed no more than to sleep for... more

We choose Barons Cove Inn for a girls weekend getaway and were very pleased with the accomidations. We had three rooms between us and all were clean although the decor was a little dated. All rooms had a fridge and microwave which was great for storing our in room beverages. One of the rooms was a loft with a balcony... more

We stay at the Barons Cove each year. It's perfect for kids because there is a pool and it's minutes from the beach. We walk to town for ice cream, dinner, coffee or whatever. Rooms are always clean and although a bit dated it serves its purpose. It is not fancy but it really is the only gig in town.... more

We stayed at this hotel for one weekend night. The staff was very helpful and kind to us. However, we were not very happy with the room. It smelled moldy. The hotel needs work. It was off season so it was $130/night and they did not have any discounts available. The continental breakfast included hot and cold cereal, bagels and... more

The staff at Baron's were all so friendly! The room was clean and cozy. There was no room service, but we were more interested in getting out an exploring the beautiful surroundings, so this didn't matter to us. The view from the rooms look out at the cove and is in walking distance to the main strip. Baron's staff had... more