3 generations of family for a 3 day weekend. Rooms are impeccably clean, sheets are fresh smelling, continental breakfast gets the job done. Rooms are also spacious, good bathrooms in each, and easy wi-fi. Proprietor "gets it" in terms of recommendations. A nice, low key, relaxing stay is easily available. Location is good as well. more

A lovely place to come after enjoying the madness of the city situated on a great part of Shelter Island with nice places to eat and drink within walking distance. We were using public transport and stopped here on our way from Boston to NY. Hired bikes on the island and discoverd some fantastic scenery and beaches. The house is... more

For our 16th Anniversary we stayed at this marvelous, romantic B&B. Bill, the owner was an amazing host with the most immaculate place we ever stayed. Wood for the fireplace in our room, french toast overlooking the creek, excellent recommendations on where to eat and historical background of Shelter Island just added to the charm. Everything was just perfect! Truly... more

Bill and Sharon were excellent hosts, and after giving us a very nice rundown of what we could do, were always available when required. All of Bill's reviews were honest and accurate. The property is located in a lovely spot and very quiet. The rooms are very comfortable and have a great view and lots of light. Breakfast was adequate... more

As we approached the B & B, we saw a great blue heron in the creek. We took this to be a very good sign. We were not disappointed. Immediately upon our arrival, Bill, one of the owners, showed us around and took us to our room. He then gave us a map and told us where to find a... more

My husband and I stayed 2 nights in Shelter Island for a little R & R. We live on L.I. and it only took us an hour to get to The House on Chase Creek. We went the last week of August and it was a great time to go (very quiet) because most families were home getting ready for... more

If you’re interested in a really cute romantic place to stay, then go for the House on Chase Creek B&B. Room no. 4 is particularly gorgeous as you get your own living room with your own log fire. Compared to the hotels on the island, it’s cheap as chips. There are lots of other good reviews of this B&B, on... more

We spent three nights at the House on Chase Creek, a small B&B near the Heights on Shelter Island (Suffolk County, NY). It could hardly have been better. The B&B has just four rooms, a tidy breakfast room, deep front porch, and a hammock strung between two trees right on Chase Creek. The owners were personable, available, and made sure... more

We recently discovered Shelter Island on the Internet; we wanted to see a new area of LI and were so pleased with the beauty, the nature, climate and of course, the seafood. We stayed an the most cozy B&B one could imagine. Our room #1 faced the beautiful creek (really a small lake) with window views in between well manicured... more