Interested in Olde Country Inn and Shelter Island Heights?
We'll send you updates with the latest deals, reviews and articles for Olde Country Inn and Shelter Island Heights each week.
Get your quick guide to the top hotels, restaurants and things to do.
| Hotel | GBP* | Distance | Rating |
|---|---|---|---|
| House on Chase Creek | £92 | 0.8 mi 1.3 km |
|
| Harbor Knoll | £147 | 1.8 mi 2.9 km |
|
| Silver Sands Motel & Beach Cottages | N/A | 1.9 mi 3.0 km |
|
| Bartlett House Inn | £117 | 2.0 mi 3.2 km |
|
| Harborfront Inn at Greenport | £177 | 2.0 mi 3.2 km |
|
| restaurant | Distance | Rating |
|---|---|---|
| Planet Bliss Incorporated | 1.8 mi 2.8 km |
|
| La Capricciosa Pizza | 1.9 mi 3.1 km |
|
| Greenport Tea Co | 2.0 mi 3.2 km |
|
| Thing to Do | Distance | Rating |
|---|---|---|
| Cross Sound Ferry | 4.9 mi 7.9 km |
|
| Beach Bungalow | 6.7 mi 10.7 km |
|
| Lenz Winery | 6.9 mi 11.0 km |
|
| Title | Source |
|---|---|
| “Olde Country Inn” | Frommer's |
The inn was quiet, which we liked, so we had the porch to ourselves. We visited with another couple on 2 tandem bicycles and the owner was very accomodating in finding a safe place to keep them out of the rain. The highlight, though, was dinner. Everyone loved Chef Marcel's creations, and his duck was one of the best I've... more
We were extremely disappointed after reading the rave reviews about this place. Not one employee made us feel welcome. The breakfast "to die for" was not impressive in the least. The soupy egga and 3 minute waffle, were delivered witha grunt by the nasty chef, who seemed boteherd to have to even be there. Not one kindness was extended by... more
We visited Shelter Island for a wedding weekend and this was one of the recommended lodging options. It's in a quiet part of the island, offers a home-cooked breakfast (included), and the owners/staff were very pleasant. We had a wonderful stay - we were in the "Rose Room" which was spacious and nicely decorated. The large bathroom with jacuzzi tub... more
We are so pleased that we chose the Olde Country Inn B&B for our stay in Shelter Island last week. We were a little weary of B&Bs, not wanting the pressure of having to socialize with proprietors or other guests if we felt like being along so we chose the Olde Country Inn because it is a slightly larger B&B... more
We live in the city and wanted a weekend getaway. The Olde Country Inn was perfect in every way. Cozy, quiet, relaxing, and quaint. Close walk to the beach, but away from the hectic Sunset Beach hotel. The breakfast by chef Marcel is TO DIE FOR. Custom made to order eggs benedict and blueberry pancakes eaten al fresco on a... more
This was by far the best bed and breakfast experience that I have had. The rooms were very nice, well appointed and nicely decorated. The best part about the experience was the restaurant in the facility. They have a truly world class french chef who prepares the most delicious meals. The atomosphere is homey and the pub is well stocked.... more
The Olde Country Inn on Shelter Island, NY (east end of Long Island)is the absolutely the best. This is the third time we've stayed here, and I can't speak highly enough of the experience. Beautiful rooms in this century-old rambling home are bargain-priced during the off season. More importantly, the food is spectacular. Chef Marcel is a master at cooking.... more
Been to Olde Country Inn? Share your experiences!
TripAdvisor has free and easy resources to help you enhance your listing and promote your property.
