I can't believe how bad everyone is saying this place was. We enjoyed it. Granted, on the outside it looked like an old motel from the 60s, but the rooms were quite comfortable. The beds were very comfortable and the linens were very clean. It certainly wasn't the nicest hotel I've ever stayed in but being in the hamptons we... more

We were tricked by their website, and neglected to visit TripAdvisor before we booked this dump. We were shocked when we arrived at the height of the "season" to find that we were the ONLY people at this place. The room was filthy, the grounds were a mess, and the pool furntiure was in horrible disrepair. My wife and I... more

I had wanted to visit the Hamptons for Christmas and had done thorough research. Since we were traveling during December there were limited hotels we could stay at. I came across pictures of the Atlantic and they looked very nice and charged a reasonable price of $150. When we got there, I was mortified because our room smelled like stale... more

Booked a group of 5 rooms, and all of us were double charged (triple charged if you include the deposit they ask for upfront at booking), i have called at least 4 times in the last three weeks to settle this up, and they will not call me back. Better Business Bureau is next on my list. Besides this billing... more

This was my second visit to the Atlantic, the first being three years ago. I was a guest on both occasions and had no idea what the cost per room was. While my initial visit was okay, this visit was demonstrably less than. The room was dirty, there was someone's old false eyelash on the floor in the bathroom that... more

Seeing as how Southampton is supposed to be such an amazing place, pulling up to this place it looked like a motel. The water in the bathroom smelled, and the bath towels were stained with god knows what. The grounds themselves needed to be treated and the walls were very thin. The TV kept going to a blue screen and... more

I have been coming to the hamptons regularly for five years, and I stayed at this property this past memorial day. I have stayed at all three properties (atlantic, bentley, and capri). The staff was very friendly and helpful, and was able to answer all of my questions. The rooms were very nice, and it was the most comfortable bed... more

So overpriced! They surcharged for "extras" that we didn't want or order or use. On a busy street, noisy. I would go anywhere else, or stay home rather than stay here again. Depressing place. more

This is for the Atlantic Hotel but they are all the same company, owners. I should have seen trouble when the charming desk clerk (as noted by the previous reviewer), who I suspect also to be an owner, had her children scrambling around behind the desk. In spite of the entire hotel being practically empty, they booked a couple directly... more