My mother has just stayed for a long weekend, thinking the hotel still had the reputation it had in the 1990's. She has been very disappointed; although the room was very spacious and had double aspect, the food was 'dreadful'. Frozen peas and chips for 'chef's seasonal vegetables', barely one quarter of a tomato with her 'scrambled egg with broiled... more

I spent 10 days there early Sept '08 and found it to be a reasonable budget hotel. Not having stayed elsewhere on Guernsey, it is difficult to make a good comparison with other hotels, however i could not discover anything cheaper. My double room on the 1st floor, (2nd fl. if you are from America!) was clean and tidy, although... more

I have just returned from a week at St Margaret's Lodge Hotel. I went there with trepidation having read some of the negative reports on this site and would like to put the record straight from my own personal experience. The hotel is perfectly located for exploring the island by both bus and car (a very efficient bus service stops... more

we have just returned from an excellent 2 week family holiday at st margarets lodge hotel.the food as usual was 5 star and the staff are very good.it is our second holiday there and will not be our last.the pool and gardens are the perfect place to spend time in the sunshine.we are very surprised at the negative comments from... more

Here are some details of a holiday . I can't beleive it !! Same room , Same problems, same things broke but 9 months difference !! Coincidence ?? You make your own mind up , I know what I think !!, short version : lift broke Aug 07 and June 08 balcony broke Aug 07 and June 08 Same old... more

Just returned from a Turkey and Tinsel break at St Margarets Lodge with 12 friends. Food was good, staff very helpful and plenty of local information available, most rooms were satisfactory; clean, warm but had very poor lighting. Excelent location with frequent bus service to all parts of the island. more

Someone else booked the St Margaret's Lodge for us - once the deed was done I mentioned to someone I knew and they gave a very negative impression of the place. I asked for opinions on the forum and gained mixed replies so I didn't know exactly what to expect. Anyway, here is my experience... Everything in the St Margaret's... more