I utterly utterly disagree with the other posters. I stayed at the Edinbane Hotel in September 2005 as part of a tour group. I found the hotel to be good value for what it is - an inexpensive family-run hotel. For the record, I met the kids but don't remember seeing any pets. Rooms - Although the dorms are quite... more

Just a word of warning to potential customers of Mr Bill Hall 'of' the management. I paid a lot of money upfront to Mr Hall and alas never got the service I requested. Time and time again I have tried to get a satisfactory refund of monies paid to him. Many written requests and many telephone calls for my funding... more

Well in reply to the person who lives on skye , i also live on skye and have done most of my life and have seen various owners of the local hotels in edinbane . This site is not meant for personal vendettas aginst people you do not like , i have been in both hotels in edinbane in recent... more

I very much agree with the earlier reviews. Dirty, dank and dismal - and yes, it does smell. The staff are surly in the extreme, and not in the least helpful. I also wonder whether the bar is for the staff or the guests. Various animals running about the place does make one wonder about the hygiene. One to avoid,... more

Whoever wrote that Edinbane Hotel was a place to be avoided needs to either stick their hand deep into their pockets and pay for five star accomodation, or else reconsider what an inexpensive family run hotel should be like. Edinbane hotel is friendly, lively and good value - the proof is the number of visitors who regard it as their... more

This place is strange and it smells strange as well. Do not go here! The food is disgusting, the kitchen had a bag of used nappies in it. There is a rabbit jumping about upstairs, every room stunk of rabbit droppings, we even found a cloth with rabbit droppings in the bathroom. There was loads of beasties in the bathrooms.... more