This place has no phones in the rooms, no coffee in the rooms, no WIFI and is out-of-date. Fish Creek itself is a great place and we enjoyed it and all of Door County. We just made a mistake by staying at By The Bay. more

Oou stay at By the Bay couldn't have been better. We stayed from 7/21-7/24. We had a room on the second floor set back from the road (#12) with a direct view of Fish Creek beach. I liked the set up of that building because you enter the room from the back and then have a door and window onto... more

Good value in Fish Creek. Clean and quiet. Great location in downtown Fish Creek. more

Located on the main street, easily accessible to beach, shops, restaurants and Penisula State Park. Desoite being on the main street, it is very quiet in the room. My view was great, toward the water, but other units can face each other, or a residential area in back. Room was spacious and very clean, small refrigerator helped, innkeepers very friendly... more

We stayed here spur of the moment when our reservation at another hotel was lost. The owners were very friendly and helpful. Location was great, just across from the small beach which our teenagers loved. We could easily walk to downtown where the concentration of shops and restaurants is the best in Door County. Room was large enough for two... more

My friends and I stayed at this motel for a weekend. It was a typical motel style room, nothing too fancy. There were a couple of very nice things.....there was a small refrigerator in the room so we were able to put our leftovers and fudge inside and there was a balcony with seating, so we were able to sit... more