Shelter Island is a pleasant location for smaller meetings and Humphrey's Half Moon Inn has been around awhile. Rooms have a nice view of the marina or pool area many with a pleasant seating area outside the room. My thought many public areas and my room could use a little work. The carpet had significant stains my the door, the... more

Very clean hotel and grounds. Attention to detail is important to the staff. Chief Concierge was the best. Humphrey's Restaurant has good food at a reasonable price for the area. Liked the ability to print boarding passes before leaving. Beautiful location and only 15 minutes away from many tourist areas. more

Booked last minute and was a little worried when the reservation came in. This was a great deal though, excellent room that looked like it had just been remodeled. The staff was very helpful and upgraded us right away upon arrival to a suite overlooking the water for first time visit. Our 3 kids loved the room and the feel... more

I was there for a conference around the area. When we got to the hotel, our rooms were not ready for check in because our reservations were not until the next day. Nonetheless, the front desk staff worked diligently to get us a room despite not having a reservation. more

Our last stay at the hotel was in July for a concert. We booked the room, dinner and concert package. We had a marvelous time! The dinner was outstanding, the restaurant is lovely. The show was great, seats were amazing (third row). Though I don't think there is a bad seat in the venue. What a place to see a... more

We stayed one night at Humphrey's. I was a bit concerned since there were some not so great reviews and this isn't your normal chain place, but I couldn't disagree with them more. The layout of the place was great. We were in a bottom floor room, I believe 6 or so buildings down from the lobby, that had a... more

Spend 7 nights at Humphrey's the first wk of Feb Must be their off-season as we felt as tho we had the place to ourselves, which was OK with us. Hotel was fairly easy to get to, clean & quiet; spa was hot, pool was cool, grounds were immaculate. Concert stage was closed. Our 1st time in SD, we were... more

Stayed in the hotel by myself the first night. Although the room was on the first floor with a patio, I felt safe. The parking lot was pretty full and the spots were tiny, so I don't recommend parking a truck or huge SUV. There was a wedding on site, which was gorgeous. There's a few restaurants down the street... more

I normally stay at the Bay Club next door and knew the Half Moon through it's excellent Sunday Brunch, great pool etc so wanted to take the family for a treat. Moral - if you find a great hotel - stick with it. The good bits - the grounds are spectacular and even with poor weather the kids had a... more