Likes: Location just a few block from the Fulton Street Metro station and the South Street Seaport. Superior room was decent sized (for NYC). Nice LCD TV in room. Nice design throughout. Dislikes: $10/day charge for WiFi (WTF?!?! - after paying $160/night for the room?). Glass bathroom door - who really wants to see their companion sitting on the john,... more

Location, price, staff, room, etc.... perfect. You cannot go wrong with this hotel. It is a gem. more

I rarely stay downtown -- generally in midtown instead. Gild Hall has very nice common areas that are warm and old school feeling in a trendy way. good experience. If I needed to stay downtown again, I would definitely consider again. more

My boyfriend and I were visiting NYC just for the night to see some friends and decided to get a hotel instead of crashing on someone's couch. Someone recommended Gild Hall and we booked it. The whole stay was great. The front desk staff was friendly and efficient when we checked in (and gave us 2 free drink tickets for... more

The staff is excellent - very helpful. courteous and go out of their way to ensure that their guests have what they need. The room was a pleasant surprise in size, accommodating 4 wormen with plenty of suitcases,makeup bags and snacks. The only drawback is as mentioned in previous posts, the glass wall for the bathroom is not everyone's cup... more

We stayed at the Gild Hall on May 29th for our 15th anniversary. I got the night as part of a package with dinner through Skyauciton.com. While we live in Brooklyn, we rarely spend time in that part of Manhattan so it was a nice experience. We felt like tourists for a night. The rooms were nice and chic, reminded... more

We were excited to stay in a boutique hotel by the Thomson Hotel company, and severely disappointed by this overpriced hotel that is not properly maintained. I am a frequent traveller & stay at Marriott whenever possible. Most important to me is a convenient hotel with clean rooms that are functional. My 1st complaint with this hotel is the bar... more

Good business hotel - great location in Manhattan, quiet yet at the centre of things. Rooms are small-ish, but not at all uncomfortable. Room has fairly good facilities - mini-bar, internet (to pay for), toiletries etc. Would be good if they can shove in a 'reading chair' or sofa ... a single seater. Also a coffee maker is sorely missed!!!... more

We only stayed at GildHall for two nights whilst passing through Manhattan but really felt involved and appreciated. The manager and concierge went out of their way to make us feel comfortable and to ensure we had a brilliant time in New York. The room was large and very well appointed and with Kiehls products. It is a little out... more