I stayed at the Gild Hall in September 2009, while in NYC for a quick break before heading elsewhere int he US on business. The hotel's great - large rooms, clean, and good value. However, the location could be a down-side, depending what you're visiting NYC for. If you're on business, you're right in the heart of things with easy... more

My husband and I wanted to spend our 25th anniversary in downtown NYC. I booked the Gild Hall Hotel based on reviews and the location. It was a great choice! It's walking distance to the Seaport, the Hudson River walkway/park, and Battery Park. We wanted to do the Ellis Island Tour and also be able to go on long walks,... more

Booked this over the phone directly with hotel after several websites (including their own) showed no availability. Location was perfect for us since we have family a block away. Room was above-average size for NY standards, interesting decor, nice atmosphere overall. Only hitch was the smoking room they originally assigned; we had to wait about 1/2 hour to be re-assigned... more

Stayed here for 3 nights before moving mid-town. Loved the location as it was perfect for exploring this part of NY and felt very safe at all times of the day and night. the hotel was very comfortable but like other reviewers did not like the bathroom door - very inappropriate. Didn't find the hotel staff particularly friendly, in fact... more

Staff were friendly, and the room was comfortable and nicely furnished (but would suggest to them to get rid of the shabby tartan throw rug on the bed - awful). Good location to Southport restaurants and shops, and located just near Wall Street. We had good and inexpensive breakfast at nearby Zeytuna each morning: yogurt, fruit, good coffee or cooked... more

Stayed here in June 09, worst weather ever for new york but this hotel was fantastic. Bit difficult to find but once found fantastic. Subways literally around the corner, as is Wall Street, having been going to new york every year for 10 years and this is the first time that I have made it to this area. I found... more

Everytime we go to New York, we like to stay in a different neighborhood. This time, we picked Financial District, so Gild Hall (of the Thompson Hotel group) was the best choice for us. We were quite happy with the place, despite being a tiny bit worried about the mixed reviews. The decor is a unique mix of old-boy British... more

OK, I did have concerns about staying at this hotel, since, I am a female, traveling alone on business. My company wanted me to stay at an affordable hotel within walking distance to the financial district. So, at $199/night this was it. I had a hard time finding it, since it is on a side street, but I was able... more

Definitely not a 4 star rating. Pricey hotel for what it offers. No restaurant or food (room service) available in hotel. Why not at least have snacks in the bar? Rooms are clean but really small. I hurt my shin on bed frame. Not enough drawer space for clothes. Closet was ok. No coffee maker or iron in room. Bathroom... more