This is a 3 star service and sized hotel trying to maintain a 4 star image - it just doesn't hang together. The Frontdesk check-in staff were amazing - but then it slowing but consistantly fell apart from there. There were issues with the plumbing in the room as confirmed by the engineer the first night - but apparently the... more

The hotel advertises a "deluxe king" room. Says its open, airy etc. But ours was tiny with barely enough space to get around the bed. The pocket door to the bathroom was very difficult to open and close. Lighting in both the room and the antiquated elevators is almost impossible to use for reading or getting the correct floor. Don't... more

Very nice hotel, with great location. Good value for money more

We got placed in this hotel after a priceline search for a four star hotel in midtown/theater district. I know that rooms in NYC are small - I have stayed there before - but this was ridiculous! The room would BARELY hold our double (not queen) bed. There was literally about 3 feet on each side of the bed for... more

When booking this hotel through a booking agent,we expected two beds in our room. The exceptionally small room contained one double bed,no chairs,no table ... very small... Those were the negatives. The bed was so very comfortable,the room very clean and the shower was amazing ... especially appreciated after a long day of sightseeing and theater-going in NY! The staff... more

I stayed at the City Club for 2 nights while on a business trip. I initially picked it only because of the location (right across the street from where I needed to go), but I was pleasantly surprised by how nice the hotel was for the price I was paying (~$180 a night with our corporate rate). ROOM: Decoration of... more

I stayed at City Club in August with some colleagues for a two day meeting. Honestly, I travel alot for work. I'm in hotels more than I am at home. So natrually, I'm not easily impressed. I have to admit I was very impressed with City Club. The staff was great- helpful, upbeat, nice and honest about where to go.... more

Location - central. Reception - lots of attitude from most of the staff, like we are a BOUTIQUE hotel! Said and did the right things with our issues and concerns, but with just enough willingness to pass for acceptable. Room - well appointed. Dark colors and poor lighting - my wife had difficulty putting on her makeup. The bed was... more

Good location, but hotel is dark and poky and not worth the money. Air conditioning in rooms too loud and becomes very annoying. More like a glorified youth hostel. more