Can't say enough good things about this place ! We stayed in the Vermont suite which was situated on two levels, joined by a spiral staircase - The whole place was just so welcoming and comfortable. The location was also great - close enough to everything you want to visit in this great city but far enough off the 'beaten... more

This is a very interesting place to stay but definitely different and may not suit everyone. It is comfortable and everyone is very friendly and I really enjoyed staying here but left then for a 5 star on Madison and when I go back, I will probably pick the Madison Avenue hotel. more

Just returned from my second stay. My husband and I work in the city and like to occasionally get theater tickets and stay the weekend. This is absolutely my favorite place to stay. Ruth and Elyn make you feel like your visiting a friends and they have given you your own suite and alot of privacy. On my first visit... more

Okay, how about this -- 1-- Great pillows. You don't think that's a big deal? Stay in the "plastic" hotels and tell me you don't sleep better on great pillows and real sheets. 2 -- Great neighborhood. You want to live with tourists? Stay in the Times Square area. Great fun but it's not real New York. At this Inn... more

We're just home from a perfect stay at Inn New York City. If you are planning a trip to NYC, just go for it and opt for the Inn. We had a warm and welcoming, but inobstrusive, visit to the Spa Suite. The bath and in-suite sauna are fabulous extras you will not find in a high-rise hotel! Cuisine was... more

Very difficult to say something new about this inn, but it is as good as everyone says and better than we even dreamed it would be. We stayed in the Vermont suite for 8 nights. It’s the cheapest of the four suites but by no means sub-standard. It’s simply delightful in every way. After a long journey from Paris and... more

We stayed in the library suite and we felt as if we belonged there. So comfortable and interesting were all the books and antiques we could just move in. The kitchen had all the convenieces and it was completely stocked with everything we needed. If there was anything wanting all you have to do is request it and there it... more

My teenage son and I stayed in the Vermont Suite. It was perfect for us. Very private with its own entrance and patio, and so close to the subway for all the sightseeing we wanted to do in New York. And a short walk to Central Park, and Museum Mile. But those are just details that will not disappoint. What... more

what a wonderful place. Quirky in the best possible way and the two lovely owners leave fresh cakes for you every day. Just such a great find and really one the the best, no THE best, places we've stayed in NYC. We had the spa suite which was superb - biggest bath i've ever seen complete with a romantic fire... more