The Holiday Inn on W. 57th Street definitely exceeded my expectations. My room was small, but clean and well appointed, with great bedding. The staff was helpful. The gym is actually a serious, no-frills local gym located in the basement, very much like the one I go to in Los Angeles (Body Builders in Silver Lake). The shop in the... more

Very tired drab shabby hotel smells badly of cigarette smoke good location but thats the only plus that I can think of more

Stayed here for 2 nights with my family. The rooms were larger than the average NYC hotel room I've experienced. Check in was easy as was check out. I rated this at 4 because the price, location and room size couldn't be beat. Keep in mind that this is not a fancy hotel. It is a bit worn around the... more

I've stayed here several times and continue to be impressed with the pre-trip help and the service when I arrived. For the price and what you get I believe it's the best deal in mid-town. You can get nicer but you also will pay $200-300 more. It's in a quiet part of town and five minutes from subways. A great... more

The hotel is old and smelly and dirty!!! I originally asked for a nonsmoking room and they gave us a stinky dirty old room. I requested the front desk for antoher room and was told that they normally wouldn't change the room but eventually they gave me another room. The new room still smelled bad with the wall papers peeling... more

We stayed here over the weekend and found it to be very nice and not too far from the main attractions. wee walked everywhere and only took a taxi at the end of the night to get back because by the time we did head back it was late and we were exhausted. Overall nice place if you are just... more

Myself and two other female friends stayed at this hotel and we were very pleased. The room was great and very clean. The bathroom couldn't be better. We paid $160 including taxes. I've stayed in other hotels for the same price which never even came close to meeting the standards of this hotel. I think this hotel is a real... more

Good sized rooms; didn't feel cramped. Only the bathroom was small. Walls were a tad thin as you could hear other folks slamming doors and such, but quiet at night. Free WiFi. Good water pressure, good A/C, clean rooms. Another guest said the pool is really nice. Great diners within walking distance. Very centrally located! more

We have stayed here before and thought we would on our recent visit to NYC. However, the hotel seemd to have gone down hill a little bit. Not in an obvious way, but more subtely. The room was not vacuumed once while were there (5 days) and neither were the sheets changed. Service was given if asked for but only... more