Recently Reviewed Hotels around Sanibel Island

Hotels in Sanibel Island

• Motels in Sanibel Island

Recommended For

• Sanibel Island Hotels with a Pool
• Pet Friendly Hotels in Sanibel Island

Hotel Class

• 3-star Hotels in Sanibel Island

• Island Inn
  ""Old Florida Inn" Charm"
  "Absolutely loved this hotel. This was our first visit to Sanibel, and I have to say that the atmosphere of the island, AND this hotel sealed the deal -- it is now one of our favorites. The hotel looks quaint on the outside -- though the grounds are absolutely beautiful and the beach access is ..."great, the hotel is just what you would expect of the older model Florida hotels. It was nice, but didn't look spectacular. Then you walk in the office and the rooms, and the modern "beach cottage" style and amenities really impress. We stayed in the Starkey Lodge, and our room was equipped with all the modern appliances -- full sized fridge, stove, microwave, etc., as well as flat screened television. The furniture was new to fairly new, and very well kept. The room was super-clean, and well stocked with dishes, cooking ware, towels (and I cannot tell you how important that one is at a beach hotel), and so on. The beds were clean and comfortable. The staff at the Island Inn can... " More >
• Tarpon Tale Inn
  "May 2013"
  "My husband and I stayed in Sea Shell II in early May and had a wonderful visit. The room was very clean and the inn had all the amenities for preparing a meal as well as a cozy table in our room. Dawn was very gracious and helpful about questions we had about Sanibel (beautiful island). She also sug..."gested watching the sun rise which we did and it was spectacular. We particularly enjoyed her flavoured water and snacks in the office open to all guests. In addition, we took advantage of the bikes offered to cycle around the island (very easy cycling, all flat). Sanibel is a wonderful island to visit and we would love to go back and will definitely choose the Tarpon Tale Inn. Andersen, Vancouver, BC, Canada " More >
• Sanibel Moorings
  "Beautiful Botanicals & Great Location......However..."
  "We have been staying at Sanibel Moorings for many years, and as much as I hate to say it, the individual units have deteriorated. Last year we stayed in a one-bedroom unit. The carpet was spotted and there were other cleanliness issues. This year we rented a two-bedroom unit. We were assured that th..."e owners kept it updated and in top shape. However, the carpeting throughout the unit was filthy, and not only needed cleaning, but total replacement. And, being it was a 2-bedroom, 2 bath unit, there was no BATHTUB! Holy smokes ~ doesn't every home have at least one tub? The botanicals on this property are unparalleled. They give walking tours of the grounds. We witnessed a most magical wedding held right on the Gulf. Plus, it's a little pricier than the surrounding developments......going to try another condo next February! " More >