After living here for a while I'm still searching for a food and wine destination. I really wanted to like this place and it's not that it was bad, it's just that for a "wine restaurant" it needs a lot of work. I'll start with the food, which was fairly good. We started with the truffle mac and cheese: always... more

Yum. Went two nights in a row to dinner at The Cellar. The Lobster Pasta dish is worth the trip and the reason I went back. The beet salad is absolutely delicious and unexpected. Desert is fantastic and made by the owners mom. Could of had seconds if it were not for the second and third cup of their wonderful... more

I have never met a chef more passionate than the new executive chef at The Cellar, Greg Englehart. His combination of flavors is beyond belief...from the truffled macaroni and cheese to the crispy brie, and the foie gras was to die for. We started with a delicious peach ginger martini in the bar, created by a very friendly and knowledgeable... more

We had the family style sampler. WOW! From the usual Caeser Salad, to a beautiful Beet Salad and a salad that featured smokey octopus. The best Mac n Cheese ever. Quail, Salmon, Fish n Chips, YUMMO! So much more and all just melted in our mouths. We ended with the Cheese n Cracker sampler plate, about 6+ cheeses both hard... more

Food was fresh and delicious. Presentation was wonderful and the wine list is very extensive with some great wines. If there is one restaurant you have to pick, this is the one, do not miss it. more

I couldn't have asked for a better experience! The atmosphere is very New York City-esque and the ambiance was perfect. Warm, glowing walls, candlelit tables and super comfy leather chairs. Our server was amazing, very attentive and able to answer all questions about the menu. My boyfriend had the fresh catch, which was an amazingly tender cut of tuna that... more

I went to the Cellar two nights ago and It was not very good food and the service was awful ...Do yourself a favor and go somewhere worth while... more

I've lived in St Thomas for 2 years now and this is by far one of my favorite places to go! The servers and bartenders are always so friendly and the food and wine is fantastic! My co-worker and I love to stop by there after work for the happy hour - wine and cheese plate please! :) Highly recommend... more

I decide to go to this restaurant after hearing from several people that this was a great place.When we arrive to the restaurant I walk into to the door and it smells like fishermans warf as if I was walking into a fish market .Not the smell that you want to get when your going into a fish restaurant.It all... more