It is well worth the trip. We ate twice at Miss Lucy's last month. The food is excellent and the scenery is beautiful. My son chased chickens and goats while we enjoyed a terriffic meal. Everything we had on both trips was great. more

My wife, daughter and I made the trek to the other end of the island to miss Lucy's for the Sunday Jazz Brunch and it was well worth the trip. Most of the tables are located under the manzana trees adjacent to the bay with a lovely view . Some tables are located inside but i did not see anyone... more

Stopped at Miss Lucy's for lunch last week. All in all a good experience, service was great, drinks were darn good, and the view by the bay was marvelous. Unfortunately, the food didn't stack up. Everything was WAY overseasoned for my taste. more

A wonderful lunch at Miss Lucy's. Waterside dining and delicious food and drink! The best conch fritters on the island! more

Thanks to advice on here we arrived before 10 am on Sunday and got one of the last tables. The brunch was a order off breakfast menu. Most items were 10$ and came with potatoes and fruit. I had oscar eggs Benedict, and my husband had pina colada pancakes, both were good. Great presentation on plate. We had key lime... more

We have been to Miss Lucy's several times for lunch and enjoyed the atmosphere and food every time. Located right on the water, the views are gorgeous and the setting is very "island" style with goats walking around the parking lot and sometimes coming to visit the tables! This past trip we decided to try the famous Sunday Brunch. The... more

We heard that this was "The Place" to have a meal and so we trekked cross-island for Sunday Brunch. The menu was unimaginative -- how may ways can you serve eggs on an english muffin? -- apparently, several. That was brunch -- not terribly expensive, but how much would you pay for an expensive egg mcmuffin without the cheese? The... more

We happened to eat here on a Friday night before they shut down on Saturday night for 2 months. To start off they were out of several menu items. We did enjoy the Feta Stuffed Chicken, The Crab Cakes and the Sushi Grade Tuna dishes. The one disappointment was the Paella. It was very dry that night. We have had... more

this is one of the best places in St. John , period.. If you can only dine once during your stay try their famous Sunday Brunch or if your lucky to be there during a full moon, they have a full moon party.... more