sticky plastic tables...greasy pizza...no view. Not really any reason to go back, unless you're super hungry and have no other options...?
Ordered a pizza for pick-up our first night in Eleuthera. One large pizza, one half plain cheese and one half conch. The pizza was pretty small for a large but tasted fairly good. Just thought that $30 for one large pizza was kind of pricey, even for Eleuthera.
The pizza was okay. The staff was friendly. To be fair, we only had a cheese and pepperoni pizza and were told that others were their specialty such as the conch and pineapple pizza. For being pizza or of the U.S. it was not bad, I would eat there again.
Ordered carry out and Jenny made our pizzas. The Conch with pineapple was fabulous. Meat lovers was very good as well. Advertsised taking Credit cards but did not on our visit. Still worth the experience and price.
Went here back in February..I had pepperoni,sausage and the supreme..the pizza tasted just so-so..similar to store-bought pizza (and not digiorno). The restaurant had a rustic feel to it. Try it out..maybe you might like it.
We stopped by in the early afternoon...excited about trying the conch pizza. Never got to. The woman working did not greet us, just glared and sighed as we tried to order. We felt like we were an unwelcome intrusion so we left. Would definitely not recommend.
Cant recommend this place - I thought the pizza was horrible - couldn't eat it! Just got a plain one - crust was weird, flaky with burn spots....and cheese was barely melted. Hubby got one with pepp & sausage - he said it was ok so I'm giving the score of 2 instead of 1! Expensive of course - not... More
Great decor, we were early as we had a 2 year old with us. Pizza was good, had the conch pizza and cheese pizza, ready in about 20 minutes, french fries were fantastic. I thought prices were very reasonable for the smaller pizzas, they also had pints of ice cream to go. Waitress/staff was very pleasant and helpful. They had... More
We arrived early, first ones there. Nice staff, recommended we order half and half because we each wanted something different. The pizza took about 20 minutes, about right. The crust was light and a little crispy, perfect. They apparently do a good takeout business too.
If you own or manage Mate & Jenny's Restaurant & Bar, register now for free tools to enhance your listing, attract new reviews, and respond to reviewers.Manage your listing