We loved it, we went on a Tuesday which is 'Pie Night'. Yorhsire pudding to start, and I had Beef & Pumpkin pie served with mushy peas, which can only be described as delicious. My partner had homemade fish pie which was apparently equally tasty. The atmosphere was unbeatable, the restuarant looked chic and the ambience was second to none.... more

Hi We went on Pie Night Yorkshire Puddings with gravy starter, Lovely! Choice of a Lamb and Veggie pie we had one of each and shared a bit of each, pastry just nice not soggy or hard and plenty of filling in the pies, Tastey. We decided not to have the Muffins for desert as we were full. The staff... more

I've just enjoyed the perfect dinner for one at Silversmiths. Tasty and tender rare roast beef with rosti starter, melt in the mouth ling with celeriac, whole leaf young cabbage followed by Yorkshire cheeses (although I suspect a Cheshire tang). A Falanghina from Benevento from local suppliers Le Bon Vin with big fruit balanced by dryness and served at just... more

Having eaten several times previously at Silversmiths I had no hesitation in introducing four others to it for a special occasion. They were not disappointed. They found the ambiance, the service and above all the food to be very good - particularly the belly pork which was deemed their best ever! I had heard they had had a change of... more

Four of us ate here on Saturday night. I chose this restaurant based on the reviews here as I don't know Sheffield very well - and I wasn't disappointed. I booked an early table as we were going to a gig at Sheffield City Hall. The restaurant was still pretty busy before 6pm which is a good sign of its... more

After spending over a year in Sheffield we waited until our last weekend to finally visit Silversmiths......what a mistake! Wish we had gone earlier so we could have savored the delights of this little gem many more times. Went with a relative, and between the 3 of us it cost £88 for three courses, a nice bottle of red, and... more

Oct 3. As strangers to the city we went along with the Tripadvisor recommendations and booked a table for the Saturday night. We enjoyed the food, the service and the atmosphere. We enjoyed two starters, two mains and shared a tempting Yorkshire cheese platter with a bottle of wine, for £58. There was no overcharging. The food was flavoursome and... more

We booked in this restaurant because it was rated the best by trip advisor. The starters were tiny, the chicken was rubbery, the steak was not of the best quality and to cap it all we were charged for a glass of wine we din't have. more

We booked Silversmiths after seeing it was No. 1 on Tripadvisor and we were not disappointed. The restauarant had a very nice atmosphere which made it eay to relax and enjoy our meal. There was not a wide choice on the menu but dishes we tasted from it were excellent and the service was attentive without being too intrusive. We... more